Best Plush Tight Top Mattresses


Our review process

We've done all the hard work researching plush tight top mattresses. That way, you don't have to pour over confusing infographics about choosing the perfect one for you. By reading this guide, you'll have an excellent grasp on what types of mattresses are available on the market, so you can confidently purchase a mattress that will ensure comfortable sleep for years to come.

Are you buying a new mattress? Here are some things we think you should know about plush tight top mattresses. Tight top mattresses are good at dissipating heat, so they will maintain a cool body temperature to improve sleep quality. They are designed to provide the optimum balance of firmness and softness for continual comfort throughout the night. With their uniform appearance, they will instantly elevate the overall look of your bed. These breathable mattresses allow air to circulate freely, keeping them ventilated and extending their lifespan. However, they are hard, making it difficult to get used to them if you prefer softer mattresses. Another downside is that they have poor motion isolation, so they aren't ideal for light sleepers, especially if you are sharing your bed.

Plush mattresses have an additional support, which is great for people who have back problems or joint pain. They feature contouring support, adjusting to your body shape for optimal comfort. They have an indentation load deflection rating of 19-21 pounds and are suitable for individuals who tend to sleep on their back, sides, or stomach. However, they may be problematic if various people will be sleeping in the bed, causing the surface to sink if there is a drastic difference in weight. Another drawback is that these mattresses can become lumpy or sag with prolonged use, so your body won't be adequately supported when sleeping.

Our Top Ranking Mattresses
Best Overall Score
An image of Furniture of America MiBasics Plush Tight Top Queen-Size 8-Inch Mattress

For a good night's sleep and endless comfort, opt for a Furniture of America MiBasics Plush Tight Top Queen-Size Mattress. This Furniture of America mattress is available in a queen-size, offering more legroom than a full-size mattress. It features a plush comfort level, providing the ideal mix of firmness and softness. It has an 8-inch thickness, so the mattress will not dip in the center or collapse on the sides. It has a tight top construction for having a firmer feel and providing a high level of comfort and support. It includes five layers, providing ultimate comfort and support.

    Pros
    • Plush mattress is an ideal option for those looking for a soft surface with added cushioning
    • Queen-size fits comfortably in most rooms
    • Includes five layers, providing ultimate comfort and support
    Cons
    • Queen-size doesn't provide ample space for couples
    • Plush mattress can become lumpy or sag over time
    • 8-inch thickness wears faster than other thicker mattresses
Runner Up
An image of Furniture of America MiBasics Plush Tight Top Full-Size 8-Inch Mattress

For a combination of comfort and support, choose the Furniture of America MiBasics Plush Tight Top Full-Size Mattress and enjoy a good night's sleep. With an 8-inch thickness, this Furniture of America mattress provides you with a sturdy sleeping surface that won't sink in over time. Available in a full-size, it is ideal for accommodating one sleeper. With a plush comfort level, it adds extra comfort, without compromising durability and support. This Furniture of America mattress features a quilted cover, providing added comfort and cushioning. It has a tight top construction, which has a firmer feel and provide a high level of comfort and support. This Furniture of America mattress includes five layers, providing ultimate comfort and support.

    Pros
    • Plush mattress for ultimate softness and comfort
    • Full-size provides plenty of room for single sleepers
    • Quilted cover stretches to fit a large mattress perfectly
    Cons
    • Full-size does not reasonably fit a couple
    • Plush mattress can get lumpy or sag over time
    • 8-inch thickness doesn't provide the best support
Additional Picks
An image of Furniture of America MiBasics Plush Tight Top California King-Size Innerspring Support 8-Inch Mattress

For a better night's rest and ultimate comfort, opt for a Furniture of America MiBasics Plush Tight Top California King-Size Mattress. Available in a California king-size, this Furniture of America mattress provides additional space from top to bottom. It features an 8-inch thickness, so the mattress will not dip in the center or fall around the edges. It features a plush comfort level, making it an ideal choice for those looking for a soft surface with added cushioning. Featuring a tight top construction, it will have a firmer feel and provide a high level of comfort and support. Featuring innerspring support, it has both a flexible and supportive surface. With five layers, it helps with pressure point relief, better circulation, and motion isolation.

    Pros
    • Plush mattress for the ideal combination of softness and firmness
    • California king-size is longer and more narrow than king-size mattresses for more leg room
    • Includes five layers, providing ultimate comfort and support
    Cons
    • California king-size reduces the amount of horizontal sleeping space
    • Plush mattress can get lumpy or sag over time
    • 8-inch thickness doesn't provide the best support
Still Need Help Narrowing Down Your Options? Here's Some Additional Information to Know:
How to Choose a Size for Your Plush Tight Top Mattress
Full-Size Mattresses

Trying to find a good full-size mattress? The plush tight top mattress might be the correct choice for you. These mattresses are designed to reasonably accommodate couples, with a cozy fit between the two sleepers. They measure 54" X 75" and are suitable for studio apartments. However, they are short in length, so they might not be a good option if you're 6'3" or taller. Also, they have a narrow width, which makes them less than ideal for people who prefer having extra space.

Queen-Size Mattresses

If you are sharing a bed or just like stretching out while you sleep, you should consider a queen-size mattress. These queen-size mattresses measure 60" X 80" and are perfect for master bedrooms. They are perfect for couples, offering enough space for two people. One downside is that they are smaller than king-size mattresses, so if you enjoy having a wider sleeping area, you should think about upgrading to a larger mattress. In addition, they are not suitable for spaces with limited room, since they can make the area look somewhat cluttered.

California King-Size Mattresses

If you need a mattress with a bit of extra room, you will want to look at a California king-size mattress. With additional length, these mattresses are good for tall adults. They are ideal for master bedrooms and measure 72" X 84". They are built to spaciously accommodate couples, providing more than enough space for two people. One downside is that they are heavy and large, making them difficult to move and flip. Additionally, they are not suitable for spaces with limited room, since they can make the area look even smaller.