Best Plush Innerspring Mattresses


Our review process

We've already done all the hard work researching plush innerspring mattresses. That way, you don't have to pour over confusing infographics about selecting the perfect one for you. By reading this guide, you'll have an excellent understanding of what kinds of mattresses are available on the market, so you can confidently buy a mattress that will ensure comfortable sleep for years to come.

Before you choose your next plush innerspring mattress, we think there's some stuff you'll want to know about. Innerspring mattresses feature firm edges, which will maintain a constant area of the mattress for substantial support over time. Designed to dissipate heat instead of absorb it, they will keep you cool when you sleep. These mattresses feature various kinds of coils, so you can choose between plush to firm comfort. They are made with various materials, giving you a wide range of foam densities to pick from. These breathable innerspring mattresses will provide proper airflow to prevent moisture build-up. However, they sometimes make a lot of noise, potentially disturbing your sleep every time you move. Moreover, they are prone to premature sagging, reducing their lifespan.

These contouring support mattresses adjust to your body for enhanced comfort. With additional support, these mattresses are a better choice for ensuring that any back problems or joint pain that you're experiencing don't get worse. They are suitable for individuals who tend to sleep on their back, sides, or stomach. However, these mattresses may be problematic if different people will be sleeping in the bed, causing the surface to sag if there is a drastic difference in weight. On top of that, they can become lumpy or sag with extended use, so it's possible that they'll be less comfortable and supportive since your body won't be aligned properly.

Best Overall Score
An image of Slumber 1 Plush Innerspring Coil Springs Green Tea Extract 10-Inch Mattress

For both comfort and support, choose the Slumber 1 Plush Innerspring Mattress and enjoy a restful night's sleep. With a 10-inch thickness, this Slumber 1 mattress can sustain a lot of weight so it won't lose its shape over time. It has a plush comfort level for the ideal combination of firmness and softness. Designed with an innerspring construction, this Slumber 1 mattress adjusts easily to your body shape. It is built with green tea extract foam.

    Pros
    • Plush mattress is good for side and back sleepers whose main priority is comfort and softness
    • Features green tea extract foam
    Cons
    • Plush comfort level can become lumpy or sag over time
    • 10-inch thickness provides less support than thicker mattresses
    • Innerspring construction tends to be very heavy and difficult to move around
Runner Up
An image of Zinus Plush Innerspring Green Tea Extract 10-Inch Mattress

For serious comfort and a restful night's sleep, select the Zinus Plush Innerspring Mattress. This Zinus mattress features a plush comfort level, making it an ideal option for those looking for a soft surface with added cushioning. With a 10-inch thickness, it can sustain a lot of weight so it will stay in great condition for longer. Featuring an innerspring construction, it adjusts well to your body shape. This Zinus mattress features a quilted cover, providing added comfort and cushioning. It features HD foam and viscolatex foam layers. It is designed with green tea extract foam.

    Pros
    • Plush mattress is suitable for anyone searching for the perfect mix of softness and support
    • Features a quilted cover, providing added comfort and cushioning
    • Built with green tea extract foam
    Cons
    • Plush comfort level can get lumpy or sag over time
    • 10-inch thickness wears faster than other thicker mattresses
    • Innerspring construction does not provide sufficient pressure point relief
For Side Sleepers
An image of Wolf Mattress Plush Innerspring Queen-Size 680 Wrapped Coil Innerspring Unit 11-Inch Mattress

For both comfort and support, choose the Wolf Mattress Plush Innerspring Queen-Size Mattress and enjoy a good night's sleep. This thick mattress features an 11-inch thickness, so after long periods of time the mattress won't collapse around the edges. It is available in a queen-size, offering more legroom and width than a full-size mattress. With a plush comfort level, it is great for people who need a comfort level that is neither too soft nor too firm.

This thick mattress features a stretch knit quilted cover, which keeps your mattress looking newer longer. It features an innerspring construction, so it will provide poor motion isolation. It includes a reversible design, so it can be flipped to prevent wear and tear. It features pressure point relief technology, which supports the natural shape of your spine reducing joint pains. With fortified edge support, it provides greater edge support to ensure enhanced stability.

    Pros
    • Plush mattress for utmost softness and comfort
    • Features a reversible design, letting you turn it over for a longer lifespan
    • Offers pressure point relief, allowing specific areas that are stressed throughout the day to receive the support they need during a night's sleep
    Cons
    • Queen-size doesn't provide ample space for couples
    • Plush mattress can get lumpy or sag over time
    • 11-inch thickness can appear disproportional in some bed frames
For Couples
An image of Wolf Mattress TDOU-1050 Plush Innerspring Queen-Size 288 Innerspring 9-Inch Mattress

For a good night's sleep and endless comfort, opt for a Wolf Mattress Plush Innerspring Queen-Size Mattress. With a plush comfort level, this Wolf Mattress mattress adds extra cushioning, without compromising durability and support. It is available in a queen-size, providing a good amount of sleeping room without taking up a large amount of space. It has a 9-inch thickness, so the mattress will not dip in the center or collapse on the sides. This Wolf Mattress mattress has a stretch knit cover, keeping your mattress looking newer for longer. It has an innerspring construction, which will is able to support numerous sleepers, including people with back pain. With a reversible design, it can be flipped over to improve the lifespan of your mattress.

    Pros
    • Plush mattress for comfort and softness without sacrificing support and durability
    • Features a reversible design, letting you turn it over for a longer lifespan
    • Comes rolled to make it easy to carry
    Cons
    • Queen-size doesn't provide ample space for couples
    • Plush mattress can get lumpy or sag over time
    • 9-inch thickness wears faster than other thicker mattresses
Additional Picks
An image of Furniture of America MiBasics Elvin Plush Innerspring Heavy Duty Innersprings Mattress

For both comfort and support, choose the Furniture of America MiBasics Elvin Plush Innerspring Mattress and enjoy a good night's sleep. This Furniture of America mattress has an 8-inch thickness, so the mattress will not sag in the middle or fall on the sides. With a plush comfort level, it is ideal for those who need a comfort level that is neither too soft nor too firm. It has a damask quilt cover, providing extra comfort. It features an innerspring construction, which will adapt well to your body shape. It has a no-flip design, eliminating the hassle that accompanies having to flip large mattress. With a U-Guard edge support system, it gives greater edge support to provide enhanced stability.

    Pros
    • Plush mattress will keep your body comfortable and aligned all night long
    • Features a no-flip construction, eliminating the hassle associated with having to flip hefty mattress
    • U-Guard edge support system allows you to have an incredible night's sleep
    Cons
    • Plush mattress can become lumpy or sag over time
    • 8-inch thickness wears faster than other thicker mattresses
    • Innerspring construction does not provide sufficient pressure point relief
An image of TFS CALMST Plush Innerspring 8-Inch Mattress

For serious comfort and a restful night's sleep, choose the TFS Plush Innerspring Mattress. This cotton mattress is easy to keep clean and won't hold onto odors. This TFS mattress features a plush comfort level, delivering the ideal combination of firmness and softness. It features an 8-inch thickness, so your mattress will not dip in the center or fall around the edges.

This organic mattress makes the air free of VOCs. This TFS mattress is designed with a jacquard cover and features a chemical-free cover, so it won't emit toxic chemicals that can negatively impact your health. It features a knitted cover, which ensures breathability and easy care. With an innerspring construction, this TFS mattress adjusts well to your body. It conforms to your body, so you will have optimal alignment as your shoulders and hips will sink more into the bed.

    Pros
    • Plush mattress for the perfect mix of firmness and softness
    • Comes with a cotton cover, providing endless softness to get you a better night's sleep
    • Conforms to your body for individualized support and comfort
    Cons
    • Plush mattress can become lumpy or sag over time
    • 8-inch thickness wears out faster than other thicker mattresses
    • Innerspring construction does not provide sufficient pressure point relief
An image of Kingsdown Plush Innerspring Queen-Size 904 Wrapped Coils Mattress

For both comfort and support, choose the Kingsdown Plush Innerspring Queen-Size Mattress and enjoy a good night's sleep. This Kingsdown mattress features a plush comfort level, delivering the ideal mix of firmness and softness. It is available in a queen-size, providing a comfortable amount of sleeping room without taking up a large amount of space. This Kingsdown mattress features an innerspring construction, supporting a variety of sleepers, including people with back pain. With lumbar support, it prevents muscle stiffness in the morning.

    Pros
    • Plush mattress is great for back and side sleepers whose top priority is comfort and softness
    • Provides lumbar support, allowing your body to completely relax and rejuvenate during the night
    • Offers pressure point relief, minimizing pain or stiffness while sleeping
    Cons
    • Queen-size doesn't provide ample space for couples
    • Plush mattress can become lumpy or sag over time
    • Innerspring construction does not provide sufficient pressure point relief
An image of Priage 8SP-Q-SET Plush Innerspring Queen-Size Coil Springs Individually Wrapped Pocket Coils 8-Inch Mattress

For endless comfort and a restful night's sleep, choose the Priage Plush Innerspring Queen-Size Mattress. This Priage mattress has an innerspring construction, which does not provide adequate pressure point relief. Available in a queen-size, it gives enough room to spread out and sleep comfortably. It has an 8-inch thickness, so the mattress will not sag in the middle or fall on the sides. With a plush comfort level, it delivers the ideal balance between softness and firmness, keeping you comfortable throughout the night while still providing a decent amount of support. It is designed with individually-wrapped pocket coils to help in restricting motion transfer between partners.

    Pros
    • Plush mattress for ultimate softness and comfort
    • Built with individually-wrapped pocket coils to assist in reducing motion transfer between partners
    • Queen-size fits easily in most rooms
    Cons
    • Queen-size doesn't provide ample space for couples
    • Plush mattress can become lumpy or sag over time
    • 8-inch thickness wears out faster than other thicker mattresses
An image of Wolf Mattress TGEM-1050 Plush Innerspring Queen-Size 10-Inch Mattress

For optimal comfort and a good night's sleep, choose the Wolf Mattress Plush Innerspring Queen-Size Mattress. This Wolf Mattress mattress has a 10-inch thickness, which provides less support than thicker mattresses. It is available in a queen-size, providing a comfortable amount of sleeping room without taking up a large amount of space. This Wolf Mattress mattress has a plush comfort level, which is perfect for side and back sleepers whose main preference is comfort and softness.

This thick mattress has a stretch knit cover, keeping your mattress looking newer for longer. It has an innerspring construction, which adjusts well to your body shape. This thick mattress has a supportive design, ensuring proper spinal support and alignment. It has a reversible design, so it can be flipped in order to provide uniform wear and prevent sagging. It features fortified edge support, so you can sleep throughout the night without fear of falling off the side of the bed.

    Pros
    • Plush mattress is great for side and back sleepers whose main priority is comfort and softness
    • Supportive design ensures proper spinal support and alignment
    • Reversible design lets you turn it over for a longer lifespan
    Cons
    • Queen-size doesn't provide ample space for couples
    • Plush mattress can get lumpy or sag over time
    • 10-inch thickness wears out faster than other thicker mattresses
An image of Handy Living Ultra Resort 325-QUEEN Plush Innerspring Queen-Size 10-Inch Mattress

Looking to sleep sweetly in a mattress made free of harmful chemicals? The Handy Living Ultra Resort Plush Innerspring Queen-Size Mattress is exactly that. This Handy living mattress features a plush comfort level, making it an ideal choice for those looking for a soft surface with additional cushioning. It features a 10-inch thickness, which doesn't provide the best support. Available in a queen-size, it gives enough space to spread out and sleep comfortably. Designed with an innerspring construction, it adapts easily to your body shape. It is eco-friendly, so it is built of natural materials rather than dangerous chemicals.

    Pros
    • Plush mattress is great for side and back sleepers whose top priority is comfort and softness
    • Comes rolled to make it easy to carry
    • Comes compressed for easy shipping
    Cons
    • Queen-size doesn't provide ample space for couples
    • Plush mattress can become lumpy or sag over time
    • 10-inch thickness wears out faster than other thicker mattresses
Need Help Narrowing Down Your Options? Here's Some Additional Information to Know:
All You Need to Know About Mattress Thickness
8-10 Inch Mattresses

Looking for a plush innerspring mattress that's not too thin or thick? There are 31 for you to check out. These 8-10 inch mattresses are suitable to use with standard-size sheets, so it will be easy to find linens that fit. They are less likely to sag, so the surface will remain level to ensure adequate support. Thick mattresses are standard size, so you can rest assured knowing that they'll be able to fit in nearly all bed frames. However, they can get indentations if there's too much weight put on them, so if you're looking for a mattress for a couple, they're not the ideal choice for you. Another drawback is that they tend to wear out quickly, so they won't last long before starting to deteriorate. If you think an 8-10 inch mattress is a good choice, check out this one.

10-12 Inch Mattresses

There are only two plush innerspring mattresses with a thickness of 10-12 inches. These mattresses are built with a solid build, making them more durable and able to sustain more weight. Less likely to cave in, they will provide substantial support, even after long-term use. Thick mattresses are standard size, so you can rest assured knowing that they'll be able to fit in nearly all bed frames. They are suitable to use with standard-size sheets, so it will be easy to find linens that fit. However, they can be pretty heavy, making them hard to transport and flip. If you think a 10-12 inch mattress is a good choice, check out this one.

12-14 Inch Mattresses

There are only two plush innerspring mattresses with a thickness of 12-14 inches. These mattresses are built with a sturdy construction, making them more durable and able to sustain more weight. They are suitable to use with standard-size sheets, so it will be easy to find linens that fit. Less likely to cave in, they will provide adequate support, even after prolonged use. However, they have poor temperature control, trapping heat and making it warmer at night. If you think a 12-14 inch mattress is a good choice, check out this one.

Choosing the Right Size for a Plush Innerspring Mattress
King-Size Mattresses

Having trouble deciding what size plush innerspring mattress to get? These king-size mattresses are ideal for master bedrooms and measure 76" X 80". They are built to spaciously accommodate couples, offering plenty of space for you to move around. One downside is that king-size mattresses are large and heavy, making them difficult to transport and flip. On top of that, they are not suitable for small areas, taking up a majority of the free space in your room. Now that you know some reasons to get a king-size mattress, if you think you want one, check out this one.

Full-Size Mattresses

Are you considering a full-size mattress? The incredibly comfortable plush innerspring mattress might be the correct choice for you. These mattresses are perfect for couples, providing a snug fit between the two sleepers. They measure 54" X 75" and are suitable for studio apartments. However, they have a narrow width, which makes them less than ideal for those who like having extra space while sleeping. On top of that, they are short in length, so they may not be a convenient option if you're taller than 6'3".

Queen-Size Mattresses

Are you curious about a queen-size mattress? The comfortable plush innerspring mattress could be right for you. These queen-size mattresses are ideal for master bedrooms and measure 60" X 80". They are designed to adequately fit couples, providing some extra space for two people. However, queen-size mattresses are smaller compared to king-size mattresses, so if you like having a wider sleeping area, you should consider getting a larger mattress. In addition, they are not great for small areas, since they can make the room look somewhat cluttered.