Best 16-Inch Pillow Top Mattresses


Our review process

No more spending hours trying to decide which 16-inch pillow top mattress you need! By reading this article, you'll have an excellent grasp on what types of mattresses are on the market, so you can confidently buy a mattress that will ensure comfortable sleep for years to come.

Here's where you can read all about 16-inch pillow top mattresses. Pillow top mattresses are good at dissipating heat, which will keep you cool at night. They are built with various coil types to offer firm to plush support for added give. These pillow top mattresses have a layer stitched to the top of the mattress, which separates the pillow-top from the comfort layer, creating a balance of firmness and softness. They have pressure-point relief, which helps ease any stress in your joints. However, they are expensive, so if you're looking for a cheaper mattress, you should consider something else. Moreover, these pillow top mattresses can smell a bit like chemicals at first, so you'll have to air them out for at least 24 hours before adding sheets. They are built with a solid construction, making them more durable and able to sustain more weight. Less likely to cave in, they will provide proper support, even after prolonged use. However, they have a heavier design, which makes cleaning difficult because two people are required in order to move them.

Our Top Ranking Mattresses
Best Overall Score
An image of Sealy Posturepedic Plush Pillow Top Queen-Size 16-Inch Mattress

For a better night's sleep and endless comfort, choose a Sealy Posturepedic Plush Pillow Top Queen-Size Mattress. This thick mattress has a pillow top construction, which adds contouring and relieves hip pressure. It is designed to reduce tossing and turning, drastically improving your quality of sleep. It has pressure point relief technology, so any pain is diminished because of essential joint support.

Available in a queen-size, this thick mattress provides plenty of room to stretch out and sleep comfortably. It has a 16-inch thickness, resulting in a bulky appearance that can be off-putting for some. With a plush comfort level, it is ideal for those who like extra comfort. It has an edge support system, adding resistance around the edges of the mattress.

    Pros
    • Plush mattress is suitable for all types of sleepers who are searching for the perfect mix of softness and support
    • Helps reduce tossing and turning at night, drastically improving your quality of sleep
    • Provides pressure point relief, minimizing pain or stiffness while you're sleeping
    Cons
    • Queen-size doesn't provide ample space for couples
    • Plush comfort level can become lumpy or sag over time
    • 16-inch thickness can tend to appear disproportional in some bed frames
Runner Up
An image of Sealy Posturepedic Firm Pillow Top King-Size 16-Inch Mattress

For a good night's rest and ultimate comfort, select a Sealy Posturepedic Firm Pillow Top King-Size Mattress. This thick mattress has a pillow top construction, which increases contouring and relieves back pain. It is designed to reduce tossing and turning, drastically improving your quality of sleep. It features pressure point relief technology, which alleviates stress in your joints and muscles.

This thick mattress has a firm comfort level, which provides the support required to keep your body straight. It features a 16-inch thickness, which provides a lot of foundational support and helps keep it in good condition for longer. This thick mattress is available in a king-size, so you have a lot space to sleep comfortably. It is made with an edge support system, adding resistance around the edges of the mattress.

    Pros
    • Firm mattress aligns your spine properly to reduce back problems
    • Helps eliminate tossing and turning at night, drastically improving your quality of sleep
    • Provides pressure point relief, minimizing pain or stiffness while you're sleeping
    Cons
    • King-size does not fit in compact rooms
    • Firm comfort level can put uncomfortable pressure on pressure points
    • 16-inch thickness can tend to appear disproportional in some bed frames
For Side Sleepers
An image of Sealy 52257562 Firm Pillow Top California King-Size DuraFlex Edge System SealySupport Foam 16-Inch Mattress

For a better night's sleep and ultimate comfort, opt for a Sealy Firm Pillow Top California King-Size Mattress. This Sealy mattress is available in a California king-size, reducing the amount of horizontal sleeping space. It features a firm comfort level, so it won't sag easily. This Sealy mattress has an edge support system, adding resistance around the edges of the mattress. With a 16-inch thickness, it can support a lot of weight so it will stay in great condition for longer.

This Sealy mattress is designed with a moisture protection cover and features an allergen protection cover, providing a barrier that prevents allergens from collecting in your mattress. It features a pillow top construction, increasing support and relieves back pain. It features a moisture barrier, which reduces moisture build-up. This Sealy mattress reduces motion transfer, so you can sleep more restfully and not sense your partner's movements. It comes with SealyCool gel memory foam, which provides deep support, while still keeping you cool at night. It features SealySupport foam.

    Pros
    • Firm mattress provides superior support to stop the body from sinking
    • Minimizes motion transfer, making it ideal for light sleepers
    • Moisture barrier decreases wetness build-up
    Cons
    • Comes in a California king-size, reducing the width of sleeping space
    • Firm comfort level can put painful pressure on pressure points
    • 16-inch thickness can tend to appear disproportional in some bed frames
Additional Picks
An image of Sealy 52257530 Firm Pillow Top Twin-Size DuraFlex Edge System SealySupport Foam 16-Inch Mattress

For a better night's rest and ultimate comfort, opt for a Sealy Firm Pillow Top Twin-Size Mattress. This thick mattress is made with an edge support system, adding resistance around the edges of the mattress. It is available in a twin-size, making it the perfect dimensions for dorm rooms and children's rooms. Featuring a firm comfort level, it helps your body keep its correct posture in order to prevent your back from bending. It has a 16-inch thickness, resulting in a bulky appearance that can be off-putting for some.

This thick mattress has a pillow top construction, which adds support and relieves back pain. It is designed with a moisture protection cover and has an allergen protection cover, providing a barrier that prevents allergens from collecting in your mattress. It has a moisture barrier, which decreases moisture build-up. It reduces motion transfer, so you can sleep more enjoyably and not feel your partner's movements. It has SealySupport foam. It has SealyCool gel memory foam, which provides deep support, while still keeping you cool at night.

    Pros
    • Firm mattress will provide the support necessary to keep your body straight
    • Minimizes motion transfer, making it ideal for restless sleepers
    • Moisture barrier helps prevents wetness build-up
    Cons
    • Twin-size does not comfortably accommodate couples
    • Firm mattress can put painful pressure on pressure points
    • 16-inch thickness can tend to appear disproportional in some bed frames
Some More Information to Help You Decide on Your 16-Inch Pillow Top Mattress:
Trying to Decide Which Comfort Level Is Best for You?
Firm Mattresses

Not sure if you should get a firm mattress? We'll try to help you make your decision by giving you some important facts. These improved circulation mattresses promote deeper sleep. Firm mattresses have a 34-36 pound indentation load deflection ranking and are perfect for people who usually sleep on their back. They allow for even weight distribution, adequately supporting your joints as well as other sensitive areas. However, they may be uncomfortable if you're not accustomed to sleeping on firm surfaces, so it can take a little bit of time to get used to them. Additionally, they can put painful tension on specific pressure points, including the shoulders and hips. Now that you know a bit more about firm mattresses, if you want to get one, take a look here.

Plush Mattresses

Debating whether to get a plush mattress? We can help you decide by giving you some information that you might want to know about. These contouring support mattresses adjust to your body for optimal comfort. Plush mattresses feature an indentation load deflection rating of 19-21 pounds and are ideal for those who sleep on their back, sides, or stomach. These back problems and/or joint pain mattresses help ensure that any discomfort that you're experiencing doesn't get worse. However, they may be problematic if different sleepers will be using the bed, causing the surface to sag if there is a drastic weight difference. Moreover, they can become lumpy or sag with extended use, so your body won't be properly supported when sleeping. Now that you know more about plush mattresses, if you want to get one, take a look here.

The Sizes Available for 16-Inch Pillow Top Mattresses
King-Size Mattresses

A king-size mattress is ideal if you want a super roomy mattress. These mattresses are perfect for couples, providing maximum space for two people to sleep comfortably. They measure 76" X 80" and are perfect for master bedrooms. However, these mattresses are large and heavy, making them difficult to move and flip. Another drawback is that they are not ideal for small spaces, since they can make the area look somewhat cluttered. Think you might want a king-size mattress? Try checking out this one.

Queen-Size Mattresses

Debating whether you need a queen-size mattress? Read on to get to know some of the facts. Queen-size mattresses are great for master bedrooms and measure 60" X 80". They are designed to adequately fit couples, offering sufficient space for two people. However, they are not suitable for small areas, taking up a majority of the free space in your room. Additionally, these mattresses are smaller compared to king-size mattresses, so if you enjoy having a wider sleeping area, you should consider getting a larger mattress. Now that you know some reasons to get a queen-size mattress, if you think they're a good choice for you, try checking out this one.

Twin-Size Mattresses

Trying to figure out whether to get a twin-size mattress? Read on to learn about some of the facts. These twin-size mattresses measure 39" X 75" and are perfect for children's rooms and guest rooms. Roomy enough for one person, they are great for providing one person more area than a twin-size bed without taking up as much space as a queen-size bed. They are easily transported thanks to their compact construction. They feature a small build to help save space, so they are great for areas with limited space. However, twin-size mattresses are too small for two people to sleep on, so they're not ideal for couples. On top of that, they are short in length, so if you're 6'3" or taller, you might want to consider a bed that is longer. Now that you know the reasons to get a twin-size mattress, if you think they're a good choice for you, take a look at this one.