Reviewing Extra Firm Foam Mattresses


Our review process

We've done all the grunt work researching extra firm foam mattresses. That way, you don't have to pour over confusing reviews about selecting the right one for you. By reading this guide, you'll have an excellent understanding of what kinds of mattresses are available on the market, so you can confidently purchase a mattress that will ensure comfortable sleep for years to come.

After taking a look at extra firm foam mattresses, we wanted to tell you about some of our insights. These foam mattresses provide pressure-point relief by supporting the hips and shoulders. Featuring a variety of foams, they offer the right amount of support. However, they may retain your body heat, making it more likely for you to wake up throughout the night. In addition, they aren't waterproof, so any encounter with moisture can cause degeneration and reduce their usable life.

These mattresses promote circulation and blood flow, aiding in deeper sleep. They are built with an indentation load deflection ranking of 39-42 pounds and are perfect for back sleepers. However, they might be uncomfortable if you're not accustomed to sleeping on hard surfaces, so it can take a little bit of time to get used to them. Also, they can put strain on specific pressure points, including the hips and shoulders.

Best Overall Score
An image of Dream Solutions USA Extra Firm Foam Queen-Size 490 Innerspring Coils 11-Inch Mattress

For a combination of comfort and support, choose the Dream Solutions USA Extra Firm Foam Queen-Size Mattress and enjoy a good night's sleep. This orthopedic mattress is available in a queen-size, offering more sleeping space than a full-size mattress. It features an extra firm comfort level, which provides complete support of your body for uninterrupted sleep. It features an 11-inch thickness, so after long periods of time the mattress won't collapse around the edges.

This orthopedic mattress has a knitted cover, which ensures breathability and easy care. It has a foam construction, which will reduce pressure points and increases blood flow. Providing a design that reduces tossing and turning, it will give you the sleeping environment you need for uninterrupted sleep. This orthopedic mattress has a supportive design, aligning your spine horizontally when sleeping on your side.

    Pros
    • Extra firm mattress conforms to the curves of your spine in order to keep your body straight
    • Supportive design ensures proper spinal support and alignment
    • Helps reduce tossing and turning at night, improving your quality of sleep
    Cons
    • Queen-size doesn't provide ample space for couples
    • Extra firm mattress can put uncomfortable pressure on pressure points
    • 11-inch thickness can tend to appear too large in some bed frames
Runner Up
An image of Restonic 5506 Extra Firm Foam Queen-Size 8.5-Inch Mattress

For a better night's sleep and endless comfort, opt for a Restonic Extra Firm Foam Queen-Size Mattress. Designed with a foam construction, this Restonic mattress reduces pressure points and improves blood circulation. Made with pressure point relief technology, it is ideal for stomach sleepers. This Restonic mattress helps reduce tossing and turning at night, which improves your quality of sleep. Available in a queen-size, it offers more legroom and more width than a full-size mattress. With an 8.5-inch thickness, this Restonic mattress provides you with a sturdy sleeping surface that won't sag over time. It features an extra firm comfort level, providing more support to body parts that are commonly stressed.

    Pros
    • Extra firm mattress will conform to the curves of your spine to keep your body properly aligned
    • Helps eliminate tossing and turning at night, drastically improving your quality of sleep
    • Designed with pressure point relief technology for additional spinal and joint support and comfort
    Cons
    • Queen-size doesn't provide ample space for couples
    • Extra firm mattress can put uncomfortable pressure on pressure points
    • 8.5-inch thickness wears out faster than other thicker mattresses
For Side Sleepers
An image of Dream Solutions USA Extra Firm Foam King-Size 490 Innerspring Coils Innerspring Support 11-Inch Mattress

For both comfort and support, choose the Dream Solutions USA Extra Firm Foam King-Size Mattress and enjoy a good night's sleep. This orthopedic mattress helps eliminate tossing and turning at night, improving your quality of sleep. It has a supportive design, aligning your spine horizontally when sleeping on your side. It has a foam construction, which adapts to fit your body shape.

This Dream Solutions USA mattress is available in a king-size, so you have a lot of space to sleep comfortably. It features an 11-inch thickness, so it won't sag, sink, or leave body impressions after long periods of time. It has an extra firm comfort level, which will properly align your spine to prevent back problems. This orthopedic mattress features a knitted cover, which ensures breathability and easy care. It features innerspring support, so it has both a flexible and supportive surface.

    Pros
    • Extra firm mattress conforms to the curves of your spine in order to keep your body straight
    • Supportive design ensures proper spinal support and alignment
    • Helps reduce tossing and turning at night, significantly improving your quality of sleep
    Cons
    • King-size can be difficult to move
    • Extra firm mattress can put uncomfortable pressure on pressure points
    • 11-inch thickness can tend to appear bulky in some bed frames
Additional Picks
An image of Restonic 5506 Extra Firm Foam King-Size 8.5-Inch Mattress

For a better night's rest and ultimate comfort, opt for a Restonic Extra Firm Foam King-Size Mattress. This Restonic mattress provides pressure point relief, ensuring your spine and joints are well supported in order to help with any sensitivity. Featuring a design that minimizes tossing and turning, it will give you the sleeping environment you need for uninterrupted sleep. It has an extra firm comfort level, providing superior support, excellent for back sleepers. It features an 8.5-inch thickness, so your mattress will not sag in the middle or collapse on the sides. It is available in a king-size, so you can have as much personal space as possible. It has a foam construction, which will require very little upkeep and can last for long periods of time.

    Pros
    • Extra firm mattress promotes a deeper sleep
    • Helps eliminate tossing and turning at night, improving your quality of sleep
    • Provides pressure point relief, reducing the stress of different areas of the body
    Cons
    • King-size can be difficult to move
    • Extra firm mattress can put uncomfortable pressure on pressure points
    • 8.5-inch thickness doesn't provide the best support
An image of Dream Solutions USA Extra Firm Foam Full-Size 490 Innerspring Coils Innerspring Support 11-Inch Mattress

For a better night's sleep and ultimate comfort, opt for a Dream Solutions USA Extra Firm Foam Full-Size Mattress. Available in a full-size, this Dream Solutions USA mattress is ideal for comfortably accommodating one sleeper. Built with innerspring support, it has both a flexible and supportive surface. It features an 11-inch thickness, adding greater durability and extending the lifespan of your mattress. This thick mattress has a supportive design, which ensures proper spinal support and alignment. It features an extra firm comfort, which promotes a deeper sleep. This orthopedic mattress helps reduce tossing and turning at night, drastically improving your quality of sleep. Designed with a foam construction, it will needs very little maintenance and can last for long periods of time. This Dream Solutions USA mattress features a knitted cover, which ensures breathability and easy care.

    Pros
    • Extra firm mattress conforms to the curves of your spine in order to keep your body straight
    • Supportive design ensures proper spinal support and alignment
    • Helps eliminate tossing and turning at night, improving your quality of sleep
    Cons
    • Full-size does not reasonably accommodate couples
    • Extra firm mattress can put uncomfortable pressure on pressure points
    • 11-inch thickness can tend to appear too large in some bed frames
An image of Restonic TempaGel Shenandoah 5506 Extra Firm Foam Mattress

For a better night's sleep and ultimate comfort, opt for a Restonic TempaGel Shenandoah Extra Firm Foam Twin-Size Mattress. With pressure point relief, this Restonic mattress minimizes tossing and turning at night. It is designed to reduce tossing and turning, which improves your quality of sleep. It features a foam construction, decreasing pressure points and improves blood flow.

Featuring an 8.5-inch thickness, this Restonic mattress provides you with a sturdy sleeping surface that won't sag over time. It features an extra firm comfort level, providing stronger balance to pressure areas that we strain. Available in a twin-size, this Restonic mattress has a compact design, fitting well in any space. It features True Comfort Core, isolating motion transfer.

    Pros
    • Extra firm mattress provides overall support of your body for deep and restful sleep
    • Includes True Comfort Core, isolating motion transfer
    • Helps eliminate tossing and turning at night, improving your quality of sleep
    Cons
    • Twin-size does not comfortably accommodate couples
    • Extra firm mattress can put uncomfortable pressure on pressure points
    • 8.5-inch thickness doesn't provide the most support
An image of Dream Solutions USA Extra Firm Foam Twin-Size 490 Innerspring Coils 11-Inch Mattress

For a better night's sleep and endless comfort, select a Dream Solutions USA Extra Firm Foam Twin-Size Mattress. This Dream Solutions USA mattress has a supportive design, which ensures proper spinal support and alignment. It is designed to reduce tossing and turning, significantly improving your quality of sleep. It features a foam construction, adapting to fit your body shape.

Featuring an 11-inch thickness, this Dream Solutions USA mattress will maintain its shape even with added weight. It has two layers and features an extra firm comfort level, which is suitable for people who need precise spinal alignment or improved blood circulation. This orthopedic mattress is available in a twin-size, making it the perfect size for dorm rooms and children's rooms. It features a knitted cover, which ensures breathability and easy care. This orthopedic mattress includes a soft cover, providing an added layer of comfort and protection.

    Pros
    • Extra firm mattress will adapt to the curves of your spine in order to keep your body straight
    • Supportive design ensures proper spinal support and alignment
    • Helps reduce tossing and turning at night, significantly improving your quality of sleep
    Cons
    • Twin-size does not reasonably accommodate couples
    • Extra firm mattress can put uncomfortable pressure on pressure points
    • 11-inch thickness may tend to appear disproportional in some bed frames
Still Not Sure Which Extra Firm Foam Mattress to Buy? We'll Help You Figure It Out:
Mattress Thickness: The Things to Know
8-10 Inch Mattresses

Looking for an extra firm foam mattress that's not too thin or thick? There are four for you to check out. These mattresses have a standard thickness, so you can rest assured knowing that they'll be able to fit in nearly all bed frames. Less likely to cave in, they will provide adequate support, even after extended use. They are suitable to use with standard-size sheets, making it easier to make your bed. However, they sometimes don't provide the proper level of support and comfort for the average person, so if you suffer from back or joint pain, then you should consider a thicker mattress. Additionally, these mattresses wear out quickly, so they won't last long before beginning to deteriorate. If you think that you might want to get an 8-10 inch mattress, here's one to take a look at.

10-12 Inch Mattresses

There are only two extra firm foam mattresses with a thickness of 10-12 inches. These mattresses have a standard thickness, so you can rest assured knowing that they'll be able to fit in nearly all bed frames. They are less likely to sag, ensuring that you sleep in the proper posture to prevent joint problems. These mattresses are suitable to use with standard-size sheets, so it will be easy to find sheets that fit properly. They have a strong design, so they can sustain more weight than other kinds of mattresses. However, they can be pretty heavy, so you'll need at least two people to flip them over or move them around. If you think a 10-12 inch mattress is a good choice, here's one to take a look at.

How to Choose the Right Size for an Extra Firm Foam Mattress
King-Size Mattresses

If you like having tons of space in your bed, you will want to look at a king-size mattress. These mattresses are perfect for couples, providing plenty of space for you to spread out. They are perfect for master bedrooms and measure 76" X 80". However, they are large and heavy, making them difficult to move and flip. In addition, they are not suitable for small spaces, taking up a majority of the free space in your room.

Full-Size Mattresses

If you want a full-size mattress, the extra firm foam mattress might be right for you. These mattresses are suitable for couples, offering a snug fit between the two sleepers. They are suitable for studio apartments and measure 54" X 75". However, they are short in length, so if you're 6'3" or taller, you might want to consider a longer bed. On top of that, they have a narrower sleeping space, which makes them less than ideal for people who prefer having extra space while sleeping.

Queen-Size Mattresses

If you're in search of a queen-size mattress, this extra firm foam mattress could be right for you. These mattresses measure 60" X 80" and are great for master bedrooms. They are designed to adequately fit couples, offering some extra space for two people. Something to keep in mind is that they are smaller than king-size mattresses, so if you enjoy having a wider sleeping area, you should think about upgrading to a larger mattress. Moreover, they are not great for small areas, taking up a majority of the free space in the room.