Best Sealy Pillow Top Mattresses


Our review process

No more reading through dozens of confusing articles to try to decide which Sealy pillow top mattress you need! By reading this article, you'll have an excellent grasp on what types of mattresses are available on the market, so you can confidently buy a mattress that will ensure comfortable sleep for years to come.

There are a ton of things to consider when purchasing a Sealy pillow top mattress. We've broken down for you below what you should know about Sealy. Founded in 1881, this company has been providing comfort for years. Sealy mattresses are available in multiple types and styles, so you can get amazing quality products without being limited in your options. They are available for purchase from various stores and websites, so you can experience the best of both worlds, whether you like shopping from the convenience of your home or prefer trying the options out yourself. Sealy designs mattresses with different firmness levels and sells reasonably priced mattresses, so you will be able to choose a mattress from an array of options. Having won The Canstar Blue for Most Satisfied Mattress Customers Award for 2017-2018, the company is highly rated by trusted sources. With high-quality materials in all their products, Sealy manufactures mattresses that will last beyond the average lifespan. Sealy takes part in clinical research and uses patented materials, offering mattresses unlike any other on the market. With an A+ score from the Better Business Bureau, the company has been highly rated for customer satisfaction, product quality, and transparent marketing.

These pillow top mattresses offer a balance of firmness and softness with a layer sewn to the top of the mattress, with a space separating the pillow-top from the comfort layer. They are built with various coil types to provide firm to plush support for added give. Pillow top mattresses move heat away from your body to maintain a cool sleep temperature. They have pressure-point relief, which helps soothe any tension in your joints. However, they can smell a bit like chemicals at first, sometimes lasting up to a couple of weeks before wearing off. Additionally, pillow top mattresses are expensive, so if you're looking for a more affordable mattress, you should consider something else.

Best Overall Score
An image of Sealy 52253351 Plush Pillow Top Queen-Size Innerspring Support SealyCushion Foam 14-Inch Mattress

For a better night's rest and endless comfort, opt for a Sealy Plush Pillow Top Queen-Size Mattress. This thick mattress features a pillow top construction, which adds support and relieves hip pressure. It has a supportive design, aligning your spine horizontally when sleeping on your side. It is available in a queen-size, offering more legroom and width than a full-size mattress. It features a 14-inch thickness, so after long periods of time the mattress won't collapse around the edges. With a plush comfort level, it is perfect for people who need stabilized lower-back support.

Featuring innerspring support, this thick mattress has both a flexible and supportive surface. It features a responsive foam core, which reacts to subtle movements, allowing it to contour to your body for optimal support. It has a soft cover, so you can have twice the combined softness. It features a knitted cover, which ensures breathability and easy care.

    Pros
    • Plush mattress is an ideal choice for those looking for a soft surface with additional cushioning
    • Supportive design ensures proper spinal support and alignment
    • Queen-size is great for two
    Cons
    • Queen-size doesn't provide ample space for couples
    • Plush mattress can get lumpy or sag over time
    • 14-inch thickness may tend to appear bulky in some bed frames
Runner Up
An image of Sealy 52255551 Plush Pillow Top Queen-Size DuraFlex Edge System SealyCushion Foam 14-Inch Mattress

For endless comfort and a restful night's sleep, choose the Sealy Plush Pillow Top Queen-Size Mattress. This thick mattress has a moisture barrier, which reduces wetness build-up. It minimizes motion transfer, which gives for a deeper rest, especially if you share your bed with a partner. Featuring a pillow top construction, it will have added padding and relieves hip and shoulder pressure.

Available in a queen-size, this Sealy mattress provides enough room to spread out and sleep comfortably. It features a 14-inch thickness, which can tend to appear disproportional in some bed frames. This Sealy mattress features a plush comfort level, providing the ideal combination of firmness and softness. It has a moisture protection cover, extending the performance of your mattress by protecting against spills or water damage. This Sealy mattress has an edge support system, adding resistance around the edges of the mattress.

    Pros
    • Plush mattress is suitable for anyone looking for the perfect mix of softness and support
    • Reduces motion transfer, making it an excellent choice for restless sleepers
    • Moisture barrier decreases wetness build-up
    Cons
    • Queen-size doesn't provide ample space for couples
    • Plush mattress can get lumpy or sag over time
    • 14-inch thickness may tend to appear disproportional in some bed frames
For Side Sleepers
An image of Sealy 52254361 Firm Pillow Top King-Size DuraFlex Edge System Responsive SealyCool Gel Memory Foam 14-Inch Mattress

For both comfort and support, choose the Sealy Firm Pillow Top King-Size Mattress and enjoy a restful night's sleep. This Sealy mattress features a pillow top construction, increasing support and relieves hip and shoulder pressure. It has a supportive design, aligning your spine horizontally while sleeping on your side. With a 14-inch thickness, this Sealy mattress will maintain its shape and form even after prolonged use. With a firm comfort level, it helps your body maintain correct posture to keep your back from bending. Available in a king-size, this Sealy mattress ensures that you'll have a lot of room to spread out and have a good night's sleep.

This thick mattress features a knitted cover, keeping its shape for easy care. It includes a soft cover, so you can have twice the combined comfort. This thick mattress is built with a responsive foam core, meaning it adjusts to small movements, allowing it to contour to your body for optimal support. It has an edge support system, adding resistance around the edges of the mattress.

    Pros
    • Firm mattress is great for people who need precise spinal alignment
    • Responsive foam core reacts to small movements, allowing it to contour to your body for optimal support
    • Supportive design ensures proper spinal support and alignment
    Cons
    • King-size can be difficult to move
    • Firm mattress can put uncomfortable pressure on pressure points
    • 14-inch thickness may appear disproportional in some bed frames
Additional Picks
An image of Sealy 51880840 Plush Pillow Top Full-Size 14-Inch Mattress

The Sealy Plush Pillow Top Full-Size Mattress is a great option for anyone who gets uncomfortably warm during the night. Available in a full-size, this thick mattress is perfect for comfortably accommodating one sleeper. It reduces motion transfer, so you can sleep more enjoyably and not feel your partner's movements. This Sealy mattress has a supportive design, aligning your spine horizontally while sleeping on your side. It features a plush comfort level, providing the ideal combination of softness and firmness. It features a 14-inch thickness, so it won't sag, sink, or leave body impressions after long periods of time. With a ventilated design, it encourages airflow and controls moisture. It has a pillow top construction, increasing contouring and relieves hip and shoulder pressure. This Sealy mattress features a knitted cover, keeping its shape for easy care.

    Pros
    • Plush mattress for utmost comfort and softness
    • Minimizes motion transfer, making it ideal for restless sleepers
    • Supportive design ensures proper spinal support and alignment
    Cons
    • Full-size does not reasonably accommodate couples
    • Plush mattress can become lumpy or sag over time
    • 14-inch thickness may appear bulky in some bed frames
An image of Sealy 52254340 Firm Pillow Top Full-Size DuraFlex Edge System SealyCool Gel Memory Foam 14-Inch Mattress

For serious comfort and a restful night's sleep, choose the Sealy Firm Pillow Top Full-Size Mattress. Available in a full-size, this Sealy mattress is ideal for accommodating one sleeper. It has a 14-inch thickness, which provides a lot of foundational support and helps keep it in great shape for longer. This Sealy mattress has a supportive design, aligning your spine horizontally while sleeping on your side. It has a firm comfort, which is an ideal choice for people who suffer from back pain since it relieves pressure points. It features a pillow top construction, which increases support and relieves hip pressure. This Sealy mattress has an edge support system, adding resistance around the edges of the mattress. It has SealyCool gel memory foam.

    Pros
    • Firm mattress is perfect for people who need precise spinal alignment
    • Supportive design ensures proper spinal support and alignment
    • Full-size provides more sleeping space that won't take up a lot of room
    Cons
    • Full-size does not comfortably accommodate couples
    • Firm mattress can put painful pressure on pressure points
    • 14-inch thickness can appear bulky in some bed frames
An image of Sealy Firm Pillow Top Split California King-Size DuraFlex Edge System SealyCushion Foam Mattress

For a better night's rest and endless comfort, opt for a Sealy Firm Pillow Top Split California King-Size Mattress. This Sealy mattress has a pillow top construction, adding contouring and relieves back pain. It has a supportive design, aligning your spine horizontally while sleeping on your side. It has a moisture barrier, which helps prevent moisture build-up.

This Sealy mattress is available in a split california king-size, adjusting to individual sleeping styles. It has a firm comfort level, so your body will maintain good posture to keep your back from curving. It is designed with an allergen protection cover, providing a barrier that prevents allergens from collecting in your mattress. It features a moisture protection cover, extending the performance of your mattress by protecting against water damage or spills. Made with an edge support system, this Sealy mattress allows edge-to-edge comfort and support.

    Pros
    • Firm mattress conforms to the curves of your spine in order to keep your body straight
    • Moisture barrier helps prevents moisture build-up
    • Supportive design ensures proper spinal support and alignment
    Cons
    • Split california king-size means you have to get new fitted sheets, one for each side
    • Firm mattress can put painful pressure on pressure points
    • Pillow top construction is difficult to clean
An image of Sealy 52257562 Firm Pillow Top California King-Size DuraFlex Edge System SealySupport Foam 16-Inch Mattress

For a better night's rest and endless comfort, opt for a Sealy Firm Pillow Top California King-Size Mattress. With a pillow top construction, this Sealy mattress will have added padding and relieves hip and shoulder pressure. It minimizes motion transfer, which is perfect for restless sleepers since any movement remains isolated. It has a moisture barrier, which helps prevents wetness build-up.

This thick mattress is available in a California king-size, reducing the amount of horizontal sleeping space. It has a 16-inch thickness, resulting in a bulky appearance that can be off-putting for some. This Sealy mattress features a firm comfort level, helping those who suffer from back pain by properly distributing your body's weight by relieving various pressure points. It has an allergen protection cover, providing a barrier that prevents allergens from collecting in your mattress. This Sealy mattress features a moisture protection cover, extending the performance of your mattress by protecting against water damage or spills. It has an edge support system, adding resistance around the edges of the mattress.

    Pros
    • Firm mattress provides superior support to stop the body from sinking
    • Minimizes motion transfer, making it ideal for light sleepers
    • Moisture barrier decreases wetness build-up
    Cons
    • Comes in a California king-size, reducing the width of sleeping space
    • Firm comfort level can put painful pressure on pressure points
    • 16-inch thickness can tend to appear disproportional in some bed frames
An image of Sealy 52255530 Plush Pillow Top Twin-Size DuraFlex Edge System Innerspring Support SealyCushion Foam 14-Inch Mattress

For a better night's sleep and ultimate comfort, choose a Sealy Plush Pillow Top Twin-Size Mattress. This Sealy mattress has a 14-inch thickness, which ensures support for heavier sleepers. It is built with an edge support system, adding resistance around the edges of the mattress. It features a plush comfort level, which is a perfect choice for those looking for a soft surface with added cushioning. This Sealy mattress is available in a twin-size, making it the perfect size for dorm rooms and children's rooms.

This thick mattress features a moisture protection cover, extending the performance of your mattress by protecting against spills or water damage. It has a pillow top construction, which increases contouring and relieves hip pressure. It is built with innerspring support and it is designed with a responsive foam core, meaning it adjusts to subtle movements, allowing it to contour to your body for optimal support. This thick mattress minimizes motion transfer, making it ideal for light sleepers. It features a moisture barrier, which decreases moisture build-up. This thick mattress has SealyCool gel memory foam, providing necessary support to your neck and back. It has SealyCushion foam.

    Pros
    • Plush mattress will keep you comfortable and aligned all night long
    • Minimizes motion transfer, making it great for restless sleepers
    • Moisture barrier reduces wetness build-up
    Cons
    • Twin-size does not reasonably accommodate couples
    • Plush mattress can become lumpy or sag over time
    • 14-inch thickness can appear too large in some bed frames
An image of Sealy 52253362 Plush Pillow Top California King-Size SealyCushion Foam 14-Inch Mattress

For a good night's sleep and ultimate comfort, opt for a Sealy Plush Pillow Top California King-Size Mattress. With a plush comfort level, this Sealy mattress supports your body in any sleeping position. It has a 14-inch thickness, which ensures that it can sustain more weight and provide lasting durability. Available in a California king-size, this thick mattress provides additional space from top to bottom.

This thick mattress features a pillow top construction, which increases support and relieves back pain. It has a knitted cover, keeping its shape for easy care. This Sealy mattress has a supportive design, aligning your spine horizontally while sleeping on your side. It features SealyCushion foam. It has SealyCool gel memory foam, which provides deep support, while still keeping you cool at night.

    Pros
    • Plush mattress is good for side and back sleepers whose main priority is comfort and softness
    • Supportive design ensures proper spinal support and alignment
    • California king-size is the ideal size for narrow but big rooms
    Cons
    • Comes in a California king-size, reducing the width of sleeping space
    • Plush mattress can get lumpy or sag over time
    • 14-inch thickness can tend to appear disproportional in some bed frames
An image of Sealy 52257530 Firm Pillow Top Twin-Size DuraFlex Edge System SealySupport Foam 16-Inch Mattress

For a good night's sleep and ultimate comfort, choose a Sealy Firm Pillow Top Twin-Size Mattress. This thick mattress reduces motion transfer, making it great for restless sleepers. It has a moisture barrier, which eliminates moisture build-up. It has a pillow top construction, increasing contouring and relieves back pain.

Available in a twin-size, this Sealy mattress has a compact design, fitting well in any space. It features a 16-inch thickness, meaning it might not fit all bed frames. It has a firm comfort level, so your body will maintain good posture to prevent your back from curving. It has a moisture protection cover, extending the performance of your mattress by protecting against spills or water damage. It has an allergen protection cover, providing a barrier that prevents allergens from collecting in your mattress. This thick mattress is built with an edge support system, adding resistance around the edges of the mattress.

    Pros
    • Firm mattress will provide the support necessary to keep your body straight
    • Minimizes motion transfer, making it ideal for restless sleepers
    • Moisture barrier helps prevents wetness build-up
    Cons
    • Twin-size does not comfortably accommodate couples
    • Firm mattress can put painful pressure on pressure points
    • 16-inch thickness can tend to appear disproportional in some bed frames
Need Help Narrowing Down Your Options? Here's Some Additional Information to Know:
What Size Should Your Sealy Pillow Top Mattress Be?
King-Size Mattresses

Not so sure what size Sealy pillow top mattress to get? These mattresses are suitable for couples, providing extra space for you to spread out. They measure 76" X 80" and are perfect for master bedrooms. Something to consider is that they are heavy and large, making them hard to transport and flip. Another downside is that these mattresses are not ideal for small areas, since they can make the area look somewhat cluttered. Think you want a king-size mattress? This Sealy pillow top mattress is a good one to check out.

Full-Size Mattresses

Debating whether you need a full-size mattress? Read on to learn a bit about them. These mattresses are suitable for couples, with a tight fit between the two sleepers. They measure 54" X 75" and fit well in studio apartments or other small living spaces. However, they are short in length, so they might not be a convenient option if you're 6'3" or taller. Another downside is that they have a narrower sleeping space, which makes them less than ideal for people who like having extra space while sleeping. Want to get a full-size mattress? Try checking out this one.

Queen-Size Mattresses

If you're looking for a queen-size mattress, the Sealy pillow top mattress might be right for you. These queen-size mattresses measure 60" X 80" and are ideal for master bedrooms. They are designed to comfortably fit couples, providing enough space for two people. Something to keep in mind is that they are smaller than king-size mattresses, so if you enjoy having a wider sleeping area, you should think about upgrading to a larger mattress. Also, they are not ideal for small areas, since they can make the room look somewhat cluttered.

Mattress Comfort: The Facts
Firm Mattresses

Interested in getting a firm mattress? A Sealy pillow top mattress could be a good choice for you. These mattresses offer proper weight distribution, adequately supporting your back as well as other sensitive areas. They promote circulation and blood flow, promoting deeper and more restful sleep. They have a 34-36 pound indentation load deflection ranking and are ideal for people who sleep on their back. Something to keep in mind is that they can put strain on specific pressure points, so if you want a mattress that alleviates pain in pressure points, this is not the mattress for you. Another drawback is that these mattresses can be uncomfortable if you're not accustomed to sleeping on hard surfaces, so it'll take a couple of days to get used to them.

Plush Mattresses

Before you buy, you'll want to know what level of firmness is best for you. If you're considering a plush mattress, we'll try to help you decide by giving you the information that you need. Providing extra support, these mattresses are ideal for those who have back problems or joint pain. They offer contouring support, so they adjust to your body shape for superior comfort. They are suitable for individuals who sleep on their back, sides, or stomach and have a 19-21 pound indentation load deflection ranking. Something to keep in mind is that they may be problematic if various people will be sleeping in the bed, causing the surface to sink if there is a significant weight difference. In addition, they are more likely to sink in over time, so your body won't be properly supported when sleeping. With this information about plush mattresses, take a look at a Sealy pillow top mattress to see if it's what you need.

All You Need to Know About Mattress Thickness
14-16 Inch Mattresses

There are only two Sealy pillow top mattresses with a thickness of 14-16 inches. These mattresses are built with a strong construction, making them more durable and able to sustain more weight. Less likely to cave in, they will provide adequate support while sleeping. However, these 14-16 inch mattresses are higher off the ground, so they are more difficult to get into and out of. You can take a look at this awesome Sealy pillow top mattress if you want to get a 14-16 inch mattress.

16+ Inch Mattresses

In search of a durable mattress that will provide exceptional comfort? Check out this awesome Sealy pillow top mattress. These 16+ inch mattresses are built with a strong build, making them more durable and able to sustain more weight. Less likely to cave in, they will provide ideal support, even after prolonged use. However, these 16+ inch mattresses are higher off the ground, so they are harder to get into and out of. These are a few facts to help you decide what kind of Sealy pillow top mattress you need.