Unbiased Extra Firm Mattresses Review


Our review process

We've done all the heavy lifting researching extra firm mattresses. That way, you don't have to pour over confusing reviews about choosing the perfect one for you. By reading this guide, you'll have an excellent understanding of what types of mattresses are available on the market, so you can confidently buy a mattress that will ensure comfortable sleep for years to come.

We've reviewed extra firm mattresses and want to share some information with you. Improving circulation and blood flow, these mattresses promote deeper sleep. They are built with an indentation load deflection ranking of 39-42 pounds and are perfect for back sleepers. However, they can put painful tension on specific pressure points, including the hips and shoulders. Another drawback is that they can be uncomfortable if you're not used to sleeping on firm surfaces, so it might take a little bit of time to get used to them.

Our Top Ranking Mattresses:
Our Top Ranking Mattresses
Customer Rating
Brand
TFS
Type
latex foam
Size
Best Overall Score
An image of TFS SOOTHS Extra Firm Latex Foam 8-Inch Mattress

The TFS Extra Firm Latex Foam Mattress is a great choice for an eco-friendly option, free from toxic chemicals, as well as low in VOCs. This organic mattress has an 8-inch thickness, which doesn't provide the most support. With an extra firm comfort level, it is suitable for your lower back because it protects from collapsing. It has a cotton cover, which is simple to wash and care for and won't hold onto odors.

This organic mattress has a chemical-free cover, which makes it a safe and non-toxic option for your home. With organic materials, it keeps the air free of VOCs. It features a latex foam construction, which resists mold and dust mites naturally. Featuring antimicrobial benefits, it stops the growth and dispersal of bacteria. This organic mattress conforms to your body, so your shoulders and hips will sink more deeply into the mattress, offering superior spinal alignment. It is made with eco-friendly fabric, so it has less VOCs and chemicals than ordinary mattresses.

    Pros
    • Extra firm mattress ensures a deeper and more restful sleep
    • Comes with a cotton cover, keeping you cool in the hot summer nights by absorbing your body heat
    • Antimicrobial benefits protect you from harmful bacteria
    Cons
    • Extra firm mattress can put uncomfortable pressure on pressure points
    • 8-inch thickness provides less support than thicker mattresses
    • Latex foam construction may feel too "spongy" for some
Runner Up
An image of TFS SACREDS Extra Firm Latex Foam 8-Inch Mattress

Do you get overheated at night? The TFS Extra Firm Latex Foam Mattress might be a good choice for you. With an 8-inch thickness, this TFS mattress provides you with a sturdy sleeping surface that won't sag over time. It features an extra firm comfort level, giving stronger balance to pressure areas that we tend to stress. This TFS mattress is dust mite resistant, keeping your sleeping environment clean and allergy-free. It has a cotton cover, making it perfect for those who are affected by allergies and skin sensitivities.

Featuring a latex foam construction, this organic mattress will naturally combat mold and dust mites. Using organic materials, it will keep the air clean, healthy and free of VOCs. It has a ventilated design, so you don't need to worry about getting too warm at night. Providing pressure point relief, it works to relieve sore muscles and joints and ensures that your body is fully supported. With antimicrobial fibers, it stops the growth and dispersal of bacteria.

    Pros
    • Extra firm mattress provides overall support of your body for uninterrupted sleep
    • Made with a cotton cover for ultimate comfort and coziness
    • Features antimicrobial fabric, making it perfect for people who are affected by allergies
    Cons
    • Extra firm mattress can put uncomfortable pressure on pressure points
    • 8-inch thickness doesn't provide the best support
    • Latex foam construction might feel too "spongy" for some
For Side Sleepers
An image of Dream Solutions USA Extra Firm Foam Queen-Size 490 Innerspring Coils 11-Inch Mattress

For both comfort and support, choose the Dream Solutions USA Extra Firm Foam Queen-Size Mattress and enjoy a restful night's sleep. This orthopedic mattress is available in a queen-size, offering more sleeping space than a full-size mattress. It features an extra firm comfort level, which provides complete support of your body for uninterrupted sleep. It features an 11-inch thickness, so after long periods of time the mattress won't collapse around the edges.

This orthopedic mattress has a knitted cover, which ensures breathability and easy care. It has a foam construction, which will reduce pressure points and increases blood flow. Providing a design that reduces tossing and turning, it will give you the sleeping environment you need for uninterrupted sleep. This orthopedic mattress has a supportive design, aligning your spine horizontally when sleeping on your side.

    Pros
    • Extra firm mattress conforms to the curves of your spine in order to keep your body straight
    • Supportive design ensures proper spinal support and alignment
    • Helps reduce tossing and turning at night, improving your quality of sleep
    Cons
    • Queen-size doesn't provide ample space for couples
    • Extra firm mattress can put uncomfortable pressure on pressure points
    • 11-inch thickness can tend to appear too large in some bed frames
For Couples
An image of Restonic 5506 Extra Firm Foam Queen-Size 8.5-Inch Mattress

For both comfort and support, choose the Restonic Extra Firm Foam Queen-Size Mattress and enjoy a good night's sleep. This Restonic mattress features an extra firm comfort level, providing superior support, excellent for back sleepers. It features an 8.5-inch thickness, stopping your mattress from sagging in the middle or falling around the edges. Available in a queen-size, this Restonic mattress provides enough room to stretch out and sleep comfortably. It is fire resistant, which is a safe choice for your home. It features a foam construction, requiring very little maintenance and can last for long periods of time. It provides pressure point relief, so your body is well supported to diminish any discomfort. This Restonic mattress helps reduce tossing and turning at night, which drastically increases the quality of your sleep.

    Pros
    • Extra firm mattress will conform to the curves of your spine to keep your body properly aligned
    • Helps eliminate tossing and turning at night, drastically improving your quality of sleep
    • Designed with pressure point relief technology for additional spinal and joint support and comfort
    Cons
    • Queen-size doesn't provide ample space for couples
    • Extra firm mattress can put uncomfortable pressure on pressure points
    • 8.5-inch thickness wears out faster than other thicker mattresses
Additional Picks
An image of Dream Solutions USA CB450Q Extra Firm Pillow Top Queen-Size 490 Innerspring Coils 10-Inch Mattress

For a better night's sleep and ultimate comfort, select a Dream Solutions USA Extra Firm Pillow Top Queen-Size Mattress. Available in a queen-size, this orthopedic mattress provides enough room to spread out and sleep comfortably. It has an extra firm comfort level, which will provide the support needed to keep your body straight. It has a 10-inch thickness, which doesn't provide the best support.

This orthopedic mattress has a pillow top construction, which increases contouring and relieves back pain. It has a knitted cover, keeping its shape for easy care. It is designed to reduce tossing and turning, drastically improving your quality of sleep. This orthopedic mattress has a supportive design, aligning your spine horizontally when sleeping on your side.

    Pros
    • Extra firm mattress conforms to the curves of your spine in order to keep your body straight
    • Supportive design ensures proper spinal support and alignment
    • Helps reduce tossing and turning at night, improving your quality of sleep
    Cons
    • Queen-size doesn't provide ample space for couples
    • Extra firm mattress can put uncomfortable pressure on pressure points
    • 10-inch thickness wears faster than other thicker mattresses
An image of TFS Extra Firm King-Size Mattress

The TFS Extra Firm King-Size Mattress is perfect for people who frequently have allergies. This organic mattress features an extra firm comfort level, giving better support to pressure areas that we tend to strain. Featuring a cotton cover, it is simple to wash and won't hold onto odors. It is available in a king-size, giving you the space to stretch out.

This organic mattress decreases the environmental impact due to it being built with sustainable materials. Designed with a chemical-free cover, this hypoallergenic mattress is a safe, non-toxic option for your home. It conforms to your body, so it offers a higher level of alignment as your shoulders and hips will sink more into the mattress. With antimicrobial fabric, it fights against any noxious bacteria. It is eco-friendly, making them resistant to mold and other bacteria and pests.

    Pros
    • Extra firm mattress provides overall support of your body for uninterrupted sleep
    • Comes with a cotton cover, protecting the mattress while also adding a bit of cushioning
    • Antimicrobial benefits assist people susceptible to allergies
    Cons
    • King-size can be difficult to move
    • Extra firm mattress can put uncomfortable pressure on pressure points
An image of Dream Solutions USA Extra Firm Foam King-Size 490 Innerspring Coils Innerspring Support 11-Inch Mattress

For both comfort and support, choose the Dream Solutions USA Extra Firm Foam King-Size Mattress and enjoy a good night's sleep. This orthopedic mattress is available in a king-size, so you have a lot of room to sleep comfortably. It features an 11-inch thickness, which ensures support for heavier sleepers. It has an extra firm comfort level, providing superior support, excellent for back sleepers.

This orthopedic mattress has a knitted cover, which ensures breathability and easy care. It features a foam construction, requiring very little maintenance and can last for long periods of time. With innerspring support, it has both a flexible and supportive surface. This orthopedic mattress has a supportive design, aligning your spine horizontally when sleeping on your side. Designed to reduce tossing and turning, it will give you the sleeping environment you need for uninterrupted sleep.

    Pros
    • Extra firm mattress conforms to the curves of your spine in order to keep your body straight
    • Supportive design ensures proper spinal support and alignment
    • Helps reduce tossing and turning at night, significantly improving your quality of sleep
    Cons
    • King-size can be difficult to move
    • Extra firm mattress can put uncomfortable pressure on pressure points
    • 11-inch thickness can tend to appear bulky in some bed frames
An image of Restonic 5506 Extra Firm Foam King-Size 8.5-Inch Mattress

For both comfort and support, choose the Restonic Extra Firm Foam King-Size Mattress and enjoy a good night's sleep. With an extra firm comfort level, this Restonic mattress provides superior support to prevent aches and pains. Available in a king-size, it offers plenty of room to relax and stretch out. Featuring an 8.5-inch thickness, this Restonic mattress provides you with a sturdy sleeping surface that won't sink in over time. Featuring a foam construction, it will decreases pressure points and improves blood circulation. Made with pressure point relief technology, it is good for people who sleep on their stomach. This Restonic mattress helps eliminate tossing and turning at night, which drastically improves the quality of your sleep.

    Pros
    • Extra firm mattress promotes a deeper sleep
    • Helps eliminate tossing and turning at night, improving your quality of sleep
    • Provides pressure point relief, reducing the stress of different areas of the body
    Cons
    • King-size can be difficult to move
    • Extra firm mattress can put uncomfortable pressure on pressure points
    • 8.5-inch thickness doesn't provide the best support
An image of Dream Solutions USA Extra Firm Foam Full-Size 490 Innerspring Coils Innerspring Support 11-Inch Mattress

For a good night's rest and endless comfort, choose a Dream Solutions USA Extra Firm Foam Full-Size Mattress. With an 11-inch thickness, this orthopedic mattress will stay in good shape and not sink in even after prolonged use. It has an extra firm comfort level, which can be uncomfortable for sensitive backs. Available in a full-size, this Dream Solutions USA mattress is ideal for comfortably accommodating one sleeper.

Featuring a foam construction, this thick mattress decreases pressure points and increases blood flow. It features a knitted cover, keeping its shape for easy care. It has innerspring support, so it has both a flexible and supportive surface. This orthopedic mattress has a supportive design, which ensures proper spinal support and alignment. Providing a design that reduces tossing and turning, it will give you the sleeping environment you need for uninterrupted sleep.

    Pros
    • Extra firm mattress conforms to the curves of your spine in order to keep your body straight
    • Supportive design ensures proper spinal support and alignment
    • Helps eliminate tossing and turning at night, improving your quality of sleep
    Cons
    • Full-size does not reasonably accommodate couples
    • Extra firm mattress can put uncomfortable pressure on pressure points
    • 11-inch thickness can tend to appear too large in some bed frames
An image of TFS Extra Firm Latex Foam California King-Size Mattress

The TFS Extra Firm Latex Foam California King-Size Mattress is a good option for anyone who gets very hot while they're sleeping. This TFS mattress features an extra firm comfort level, which encourages deeper sleep. Available in a California king-size, it offers additional room from bottom to top. With a cotton cover, it is simple to wash and won't retain odors. It is resistant to dust mites, protecting you against the factors that can contribute to allergic reactions.

This TFS mattress features a latex foam construction, which resists mold and dust mites naturally. Using organic materials, it will keep the air clean, purified and free of toxins. It has a ventilated design, ensuring that you stay cool and relaxed throughout the night. With antimicrobial benefits, it prevents the spread of bacteria. This TFS mattress has pressure point relief technology, ensuring your spine and joints are well supported in order to help with any sensitivity.

    Pros
    • Extra firm mattress ensures a deeper and more restful sleep
    • Designed with a cotton cover for maximum comfort and coziness
    • Antimicrobial benefits ensure a healthier sleep area
    Cons
    • California king-size reduces the width of sleeping space
    • Extra firm mattress can put uncomfortable pressure on pressure points
    • Latex foam construction might feel too "spongy" for some
Still Need Some Help Narrowing Down Your Options? Here's Some Additional Information to Consider:
Mattress Type: Which Is the Best Choice for You?
Memory Foam Mattresses

If you're thinking about getting a memory foam mattress, this extra firm mattress might be a good choice. Built of various materials, these mattresses offer just the right amount of comfort for you. With pressure-point relief, they will eliminate any soreness in your joints. They have superior motion isolation, which will make sure you don't wake your partner with your vigorous movements during the night, unlike conventional spring mattresses. However, they can smell a bit like chemicals initially, sometimes lasting up to a couple of weeks before wearing off. Additionally, these mattresses aren't waterproof, so any encounter with moisture can cause degeneration and reduce their usable life.

Latex Foam Mattresses

If you're thinking about getting a latex foam mattress, this extra firm mattress could be a good choice for you. Latex foam mattresses are made from various materials, giving you a range of foam densities to choose from. They have a breathable design, so there is adequate ventilation and airflow. Latex foam mattresses are good at dissipating heat instead of absorbing it, providing a cool sleep temperature. With pressure-point relief, they will eliminate any tension in your joints. They are low VOC (volatile organic compounds), which will not emit odorous gases, unlike many synthetic mattresses which can "off gas" chemicals. Something to keep in mind is that they are expensive, so if you're on a budget, this might not be the best choice for you. Moreover, these latex foam mattresses can smell a bit like chemicals initially, so you should air them out for at least 24 hours before putting sheets on.

Pillow Top Mattresses

If you want a pillow top mattress, this extra firm mattress could be a good choice for you. Moving heat away from your body, pillow top mattresses keep you from getting too hot throughout the night. They come with pressure-point relief, providing contoured support to sensitive areas like your hips and shoulders. They have an extra layer of padding, which will offer the appropriate cushion. They have a layer sewn to the top of the mattress for continuous comfort throughout the night. They feature enhanced motion isolation, which will enable you to move without waking your partner. Something to consider is that they are more costly than other kinds of mattresses, so if you're searching for a cheaper mattress, you should consider something else. In addition, these pillow top mattresses can smell a bit like chemicals initially, so you should air them out for at least 24 hours before putting sheets on.

Mattress Thickness: What to Know Before You Decide on Your Extra Firm Mattress
Under 6 Inch Mattresses

There are only two extra firm mattresses that have a thickness of less than six inches. These under 6 inch mattresses are suitable to use with standard-size sheets, so it will be easy to find sheets that fit. They are easy to carry, due to their lightweight construction. These mattresses are perfect for trundle beds, so they are convenient for guests. However, they provide less support than other kinds of mattresses, so if you are prone to joint or back pain, then you should consider a thicker mattress. Another drawback is that these mattresses tend to wear out quickly, so they will need to be replaced more frequently. If you think an under 6 inch mattress is a good choice, take a look at this extra firm mattress.

8-10 Inch Mattresses

Trying to find an extra firm mattress that's not too thin or thick? Check out an 8-10 inch mattress like this comfortable one. Designed with a standard thickness, these mattresses will fit in nearly all bed frames. They are suitable to use with standard-size sheets, so it will be easy to find linens that fit. Less likely to cave in, they will provide adequate support while sleeping. Something to keep in mind is that they wear out quickly, so you will have to replace them more frequently. Another downside is that they might get indentations if there's too much weight put on them, so if you're looking for a mattress for two, they're not a great choice for you. We hope picking out the right extra firm mattress will feel a bit easier after these quick facts on 8-10 inch mattresses.

10-12 Inch Mattresses

There are only two extra firm mattresses with a thickness of 10-12 inches. These mattresses are suitable to use with standard-size sheets, which ensures you will never have issues finding sheets that fit. Less likely to cave in, they will continue to hold their structure and provide proper support over time. They have a strong design, making them more durable and able to sustain more weight. They have a standard thickness, so you can rest assured knowing that they'll be able to fit in nearly all bed frames. One downside is that they are higher off the ground, so getting into and out of bed is more difficult than it would be with a thinner mattress. If you think a 10-12 inch mattress is a good choice, check out this one.

Choosing the Right Size for an Extra Firm Mattress
King-Size Mattresses

Having trouble deciding what size extra firm mattress to get? These king-size mattresses are ideal for master bedrooms and measure 76" X 80". They are built to spaciously accommodate couples, offering extra space for two people. However, these mattresses are large and heavy, making them difficult to transport and flip. In addition, they are not ideal for spaces with limited room, making small areas look somewhat cluttered. Considering getting a king-size mattress? Take a look at this one.

Full-Size Mattresses

If you're in search of a full-size mattress, the super comfortable extra firm mattress could be right for you. Full-size mattresses are perfect for couples, with a snug fit between the two sleepers. They measure 54" X 75" and fit in studio apartments. Something to consider is that they are short in length, so they might not be a suitable option if you're taller than 6'3". Additionally, full-size mattresses have a narrow width, so you will have limited space to move when sharing your bed with another person.

Queen-Size Mattresses

Trying to find a good queen-size mattress? The super comfortable extra firm mattress could be right for you. Queen-size mattresses are suitable for couples, providing enough space for two people. They measure 60" X 80" and are ideal for master bedrooms. However, they are not ideal for areas with limited room, since they can make the area look even smaller. Also, queen-size mattresses are smaller than king-size mattresses, so if you like having extra space while sleeping, you should consider getting a larger mattress.