Reviewing Pillow Top Mattresses


Our review process

No more reading through dozens of confusing articles to try to decide which pillow top mattress to get! By reading this guide, you'll have an excellent grasp on what types of mattresses are available on the market, so you can confidently buy a mattress that will ensure comfortable sleep for years to come.

After reviewing pillow top mattresses, here is some important information we think you should know. Moving heat away from your body, pillow top mattresses ensure that you'll stay cool throughout the night. They have various types of coils, so you can choose between plush to firm comfort. Designed to provide the optimal balance of firmness and softness, these mattresses add a balance of flexibility and support and won't easily sink over time. With pressure-point relief, they will alleviate any tension in your joints. However, they can smell a bit like chemicals at first, so you should air them out for at least 24 hours before putting sheets on. In addition, they are more costly than other kinds of mattresses, so if you're looking for a more affordable mattress, you should consider something else.

Best Overall Score
An image of Slumberland Platinum Seal Pillow Top 2400 Pocket Springs Mattress

The Slumberland Platinum Seal Pillow Top Mattress is ideal for people who frequently have allergies. This hypoallergenic mattress ensures a quality night's sleep. This Slumberland mattress has an EdgeMax support system, adding resistance around the edges of the mattress. It features a Belgium damask cover, providing an elegant and tasteful element to the mattress design. It has a pillow top construction, which adds contouring and relieves hip pressure. Contouring to your body, this Slumberland mattress is unique to each individual by targeting your body's specific stress areas. Designed with pressure point relief technology, it increases comfort and alleviates pain.

    Pros
    • Offers pressure point relief, making it perfect for people who sleep on their stomach
    • Designed to fit your body for increase comfort and support
    Cons
    • Pillow top construction is difficult to clean
Runner Up
An image of Wolf Mattress PSFP-1050 Plush Pillow Top Queen-Size 560 Wrapped Coil Innerspring Individually Wrapped Pocket Coils 10-Inch Mattress

For a good night's sleep and ultimate comfort, opt for a Wolf Mattress Plush Pillow Top Queen-Size Mattress. Available in a queen-size, this thick mattress provides enough room to spread out and sleep comfortably. It features a 10-inch thickness, keeping your mattress functional for years. With a plush comfort level, it is great for people who need a comfort level that is neither too soft nor too firm.

This thick mattress features a pillow top construction, increasing contouring and relieves hip and shoulder pressure. It features a stretch knit quilted cover, keeping your mattress looking newer for longer. This thick mattress has individually-wrapped pocket coils so that it minimizes pressure points and optimizes comfort. It conforms to your body for special support and comfort. This thick mattress has a supportive design, aligning your spine horizontally when sleeping on your side. It has fortified edge support, which offers you to have an exceptional night's sleep.

    Pros
    • Plush mattress is perfect for back and side sleepers whose main preference is comfort and softness
    • Built with individually-wrapped pocket coils to keep the mattress fresh and cool during the night
    • Supportive design ensures proper spinal support and alignment
    Cons
    • Queen-size doesn't provide ample space for couples
    • Plush mattress can get lumpy or sag over time
    • 10-inch thickness wears faster than other thicker mattresses
For Side Sleepers
An image of Safavieh MAT1002A-Q Plush Pillow Top Queen-Size 10-Inch Mattress

For a good night's rest and endless comfort, opt for a Safavieh Plush Pillow Top Queen-Size Mattress. With a plush comfort level, this Safavieh mattress is great for those who need stabilized lower-back support. Available in a queen-size, it provides plenty of space to spread out and sleep comfortably. Featuring a 10-inch thickness, this Safavieh mattress can sustain a lot of weight so it won't sink in easily. With a pillow top construction, it will have extra padding and relieves hip and shoulder pressure. Equipped with innovative pressure point relief technology, it increases comfort and alleviates pain. This Safavieh mattress has a supportive design, aligning your spine horizontally while sleeping on your side.

    Pros
    • Plush mattress for softness and comfort without sacrificing durability and support
    • Includes heavy gauge metal coils, giving you better body conforming and lower motion transfer
    • Offers pressure point relief, reducing pain or stiffness while sleeping
    Cons
    • Queen-size doesn't provide ample space for couples
    • Plush mattress can become lumpy or sag over time
    • 10-inch thickness wears out faster than other thicker mattresses
For Couples
An image of Helix Dusk Luxe Medium Firm Pillow Top Queen-Size 14-Inch Individually Wrapped Pocket Coils Thick Mattress

For a good night's sleep and endless comfort, opt for a Helix Dusk Luxe Medium Firm Pillow Top Queen-Size Mattress. With a pillow top construction, this HELIX mattress will have extra padding and relieves hip and shoulder pressure. It has a supportive design, aligning your spine horizontally while sleeping on your side. Contouring to your body, this thick mattress provides just the correct amount of comfort and support.

This HELIX mattress features gel Visco memory foam, Helix Dynamic Foam, poly foam, and Duradense Foam layers. Available in a queen-size, it provides enough space to stretch out and sleep comfortably. Featuring a 14-inch thickness, this HELIX mattress will stay in good shape and not sink in even after prolonged use. It has four layers and features a medium firm comfort level, giving stronger balance to pressure areas that we tend to stress.

This HELIX mattress has a Helix Ultra cool cover, which is designed of a special material made to absorb excess heat and keep you cool at night. It has individually-wrapped pocket coils to assist in reducing motion transfer between partners. It has a 100 night sleep trial, which means that if it doesn't feel like the perfect mattress for you after that time, you can return it free of charge. This HELIX mattress is built with an edge support system, adding resistance around the edges of the mattress.

    Pros
    • Medium firm comfort level is great for people who require precise spinal alignment
    • Contours to the natural curves of your body for exceptional pressure point relief
    • Supportive design ensures proper spinal support and alignment
    Cons
    • Queen-size doesn't provide ample space for couples
    • Medium firm comfort level can put uncomfortable pressure on pressure points
    • 14-inch thickness may appear too large in some bed frames
For Back Sleepers
An image of Dream Solutions USA CB450Q Extra Firm Pillow Top Queen-Size 490 Innerspring Coils 10-Inch Mattress

For both comfort and support, choose the Dream Solutions USA Extra Firm Pillow Top Queen-Size Mattress and enjoy a good night's sleep. This orthopedic mattress helps reduce tossing and turning at night, which increases your quality of sleep. It has a supportive design, aligning your spine horizontally when sleeping on your side. It features a pillow top construction, adding support and relieves back pain.

Featuring a 10-inch thickness, this orthopedic mattress will maintain its shape and form even after prolonged use. With an extra firm comfort level, it is great for those who rest on their back since it provides deeper spinal support. Available in a queen-size, this thick mattress provides enough room to stretch out and sleep comfortably. It features a knitted cover, which ensures breathability and easy care.

    Pros
    • Extra firm mattress conforms to the curves of your spine in order to keep your body straight
    • Supportive design ensures proper spinal support and alignment
    • Helps reduce tossing and turning at night, improving your quality of sleep
    Cons
    • Queen-size doesn't provide ample space for couples
    • Extra firm mattress can put uncomfortable pressure on pressure points
    • 10-inch thickness wears faster than other thicker mattresses
Additional Picks
An image of Helix Twilight Firm Pillow Top Queen-Size 10-Inch Individually Wrapped Pocket Coils Thick Mattress

For a good night's rest and endless comfort, select a Helix Twilight Firm Pillow Top Queen-Size Mattress. This HELIX mattress offers pressure point relief, reducing and alleviating tension in your muscles and joints. It has a supportive design, aligning your spine horizontally while sleeping on your side. Featuring a pillow top construction, it will have extra padding and relieves back pain.

Available in a queen-size, this thick mattress gives enough room to stretch out and sleep comfortably. With a 10-inch thickness, it can sustain a lot of weight so it will stay in great condition for longer. It includes four layers and features a firm comfort level, providing superior support to prevent the body from sinking. It has gel Visco memory foam, Memory Plus Foam, poly foam, and Duradense Foam layers.

This thick mattress features a Helix Ultra cool cover, which is designed of a special material made to absorb excess heat and keep you cool at night. With a cooling cover, it is ideal if you tend to overheat at night. This thick mattress includes individually-wrapped pocket coils, so it reduces pressure points and optimizes comfort. It features a 100 night sleep trial, which means that if it doesn't feel like the perfect mattress for you after that time, you can return it free of charge.

    Pros
    • Firm comfort level is perfect for people who need precise spinal alignment
    • Pressure point relief technology ensures that your weight is evenly distributed on the mattress
    • Supportive design ensures proper spinal support and alignment
    Cons
    • Queen-size doesn't provide ample space for couples
    • Firm comfort level can put uncomfortable pressure on pressure points
    • 10-inch thickness wears faster than other thicker mattresses
An image of Stearns and Foster Estate Plush Pillow Top Queen-Size StabiLux Edge System 14.5-Inch Mattress

For a good night's sleep and endless comfort, choose a Stearns and Foster Estate Plush Pillow Top Queen-Size Mattress. This thick mattress has a plush comfort level, which is suitable for anyone searching for the perfect mix of softness and support. It is available in a queen-size, offering more legroom and width than a full-size mattress. It features a 14.5-inch thickness, resulting in a bulky appearance. It features a pillow top construction, which increases support and relieves hip pressure. With pressure point relief, it works to eliminate any excessive pressure that may cause discomfort to any sore muscles or joints.

    Pros
    • Plush mattress is an ideal choice for those looking for a soft surface with added cushioning
    • Offers pressure point relief, reducing and alleviating tension in your muscles and joints
    • Queen-size fits comfortably in most rooms
    Cons
    • Queen-size doesn't provide ample space for couples
    • Plush comfort level can get lumpy or sag over time
    • 14.5-inch thickness may appear disproportional in some bed frames
An image of Wolf Mattress Plush Pillow Top Queen-Size 288 Innerspring 8-Inch Mattress

For a good night's sleep and endless comfort, opt for a Wolf Mattress Plush Pillow Top Queen-Size Mattress. Available in a queen-size, this Wolf Mattress mattress offers more legroom and more width than a full-size mattress. It features an 8-inch thickness, so your mattress will not dip in the center or fall on the sides. Featuring a plush comfort level, it is good for people who are looking for extra cushioning, without compromising durability and support. It has a pillow top construction, which adds support and relieves hip pressure. This Wolf Mattress mattress has a quilted cover, providing added comfort and cushioning. It is suitable to use for adjustable bed bases, platform beds, and standard box springs.

    Pros
    • Plush mattress is good for side and back sleepers whose top preference is comfort and softness
    • Comes rolled, making it easy to place your mattress on the bed of your choice
    • Features a vacuum packed design, making it easy to carry it into the room you'd like
    Cons
    • Queen-size doesn't provide ample space for couples
    • Plush mattress can get lumpy or sag over time
    • 8-inch thickness wears faster than other thicker mattresses
An image of Priage Medium Firm Pillow Top Queen-Size Individually Wrapped Pocket Coils 10-Inch Mattress

For both comfort and support, choose the Priage Medium Firm Pillow Top Queen-Size Mattress and enjoy a restful night's sleep. Available in a queen-size, this Priage mattress provides plenty of room to spread out and sleep comfortably. It is built with individually-wrapped pocket coils to keep the mattress fresh and cool throughout the night. With a medium firm comfort level, it is great for those who rest on their back since it offers deeper spinal support. This Priage mattress eliminates motion transfer, making it ideal for light sleepers. It is designed to reduce tossing and turning, which significantly improves your quality of sleep. Featuring a 10-inch thickness, this thick mattress can support a lot of weight so it will stay in great condition for longer. With two layers, it supplies you with stronger pain relief and evenly disperses heat to keep you cool while sleeping. This Priage mattress features a pillow top construction, increasing contouring and relieves back pain.

    Pros
    • Medium firm mattress helps your body maintain good posture to prevent your back from curving
    • Built with individually-wrapped pocket coils to keep the mattress fresh and cool throughout the night
    • Eliminates motion transfer, making it ideal for restless sleepers
    Cons
    • Queen-size doesn't provide ample space for couples
    • Medium firm mattress can put painful pressure on pressure points
    • 10-inch thickness wears faster than other thicker mattresses
An image of Coaster Home Furnishings Ultra Plush Pillow Top Queen-Size 13-Inch Mattress

The Coaster Home Furnishings Ultra Plush Pillow Top Queen-Size Mattress is best for those looking for an allergen-free mattress. This hypoallergenic mattress is dust mite resistant so that you are less exposed to allergens while sleeping. Available in a queen-size, it gives enough space to spread out and sleep comfortably. It has an ultra plush comfort level, which is an ideal option for those looking for a soft surface with additional cushioning. With hypoallergenic materials, it is excellent for those who have allergies or skin sensitivities. It features a 13-inch thickness, so after long periods of time it won't sag in the middle.

This hypoallergenic mattress features a pillow top construction, which increases support and relieves back pain. Featuring a design that conforms to your body, it provides the right amount of support and comfort. It has pressure point relief technology for enhanced spinal and joint support. It has a support edge technology to provide the support you need to sleep right up to the edge of the mattress.

    Pros
    • Ultra plush mattress allows for a much softer sleeping surface
    • Conforms to the natural curves of your body, enhancing its overall comfort and support
    • Provides pressure point relief, decreasing pain or stiffness while you're sleeping
    Cons
    • Queen-size doesn't provide ample space for couples
    • Ultra plush mattress can get lumpy or sag over time
    • 13-inch thickness may appear too large in some bed frames
Need Help Narrowing Down Your Options? Here's Some Additional Information to Know:
Find Out Which Mattress Will Best Suit Your Needs
Firm Mattresses

If you want a firm mattress, a pillow top mattress could be a good choice for you. These mattresses evenly distribute your body weight to support your back and other sensitive areas. Providing improved circulation and blood flow, they promote deeper sleep. They have an indentation load deflection rating of 34-36 pounds and are ideal for those who tend to sleep on their back. However, they may be uncomfortable if you're not accustomed to sleeping on firm surfaces, so it can take a couple of days to get used to them. In addition, these mattresses can put painful tension on specific pressure points, including the shoulders and hips.

Ultra Plush Mattresses

Looking for a good ultra plush mattress? Consider a pillow top mattress. With extra support, these mattresses are a preferable choice for making sure that any back problems or joint pain that you're experiencing don't get worse. These contouring support mattresses adjust to your body shape for enhanced comfort. They are suitable for people who sleep on their sides and are built with an indentation load deflection rating of 14-19 pounds. However, ultra plush mattresses may be problematic if various people will be sleeping in the bed, causing the surface to sink if there is a significant difference in weight. Additionally, they usually become softer over time, so you'll have to replace them more often than other types of mattresses.

Extra Firm Mattresses

Looking for a good extra firm mattress? Consider a pillow top mattress. Extra firm mattresses are perfect for those who sleep on their back and are built with a 39-42 pound indentation load deflection rating. Providing improved circulation and blood flow, they promote deeper sleep. These mattresses offer proper weight distribution, supporting your back and other sensitive areas. However, they can put strain on specific pressure points, including the shoulders and hips. Moreover, extra firm mattresses can be uncomfortable if you're not accustomed to sleeping on hard surfaces, so it might take a few days to get used to them.

All About Mattress Thickness for Pillow Top Mattresses
Under 6 Inch Mattresses

There are only two pillow top mattresses that have a thickness of less than six inches. These mattresses can be carried easily due to their compact build. Ideal for trundle beds, they are convenient for sleepovers. These under 6 inch mattresses are suitable to use with standard-size sheets, so it will be easy to find sheets that fit. However, they wear out quickly, so they won't last long before starting to deteriorate. In addition, they sometimes don't provide the adequate level of comfort and support for the average person, so if you suffer from joint or back pain, then you should consider a thicker mattress. Take a look at this pillow top mattress if a mattress with under 6 inch thickness is what you're looking for.

6-8 Inch Mattresses

There are only two pillow top mattresses with a thickness of 6-8 inches. These mattresses can be carried easily due to their compact construction. They are suitable to use with standard-size sheets, so it will be easy to find linens that fit. They are ideal for trundle beds, which can easily be stowed away when not in use. Something to keep in mind is that they tend to wear out quickly, so you will have to replace them more frequently. Also, they might get indentations if there's too much weight put on them, so if you're looking for a mattress for a couple, they're not the best choice for you. You can take a look at this pillow top mattress if a mattress with 6-8 inch thickness is what you're looking for.

8-10 Inch Mattresses

Trying to find a pillow top mattress that will provide the perfect amount of comfort and support? There are 19 for you to take a look at. Less likely to cave in, these 8-10 inch mattresses will provide substantial support, even after long-term use. They have a standard thickness, so you can rest assured knowing that they'll fit in nearly all bed frames. These 8-10 inch mattresses are suitable to use with standard-size sheets, so it will be easy to find sheets that fit. However, they might get indentations if there's too much weight put on them, so if you're looking for a mattress for two, they're not a great choice for you. In addition, they wear out quickly, so you will have to replace them more frequently. You can take a look at this awesome pillow top mattress if a mattress with 8-10 inch thickness is what you're looking for.

What Size Should Your Pillow Top Mattress Be?
King-Size Mattresses

If you like having lots of room while you sleep, you will want to look at a king-size mattress. These mattresses are ideal for couples, offering more than enough space for two people. They measure 76" X 80" and are perfect for master bedrooms. Something to keep in mind is that they are not ideal for areas with limited room, making small areas look somewhat cluttered. In addition, they are heavy and large, making them difficult to transport and flip.

Full-Size Mattresses

Looking for a good full-size mattress? This incredibly comfortable pillow top mattress could be right for you. These full-size mattresses measure 54" X 75" and fit well in studio apartments. They are suitable for couples, with a snug fit between the two sleepers. Something to keep in mind is that they have a narrow width, so you will have limited space to move around when sharing your bed with someone else. Additionally, these mattresses are short in length, so they may not be a good option if you're taller than 6'3".

Queen-Size Mattresses

Looking for a good queen-size mattress? This super comfortable pillow top mattress could be right for you. These mattresses are perfect for couples, offering enough space for two people. They measure 60" X 80" and are ideal for master bedrooms. One downside is that they are not suitable for small areas, since they can make the room look somewhat cluttered. Another drawback is that these mattresses are smaller than king-size mattresses, so if you enjoy having extra space while sleeping, you should consider upgrading to a larger mattress.