Unbiased 16-Inch Plush Mattresses Review

Our review process

We've already done all the heavy lifting researching 16-inch plush mattresses. That way, you don't have to pour over confusing reviews about selecting the right one for you. By reading this guide, you'll have an excellent grasp on what kinds of mattresses are available on the market, so you can confidently purchase a mattress that will ensure comfortable sleep for years to come.

Looking to feel re-energized and enjoy a peaceful night's sleep? Consider getting a 16-inch plush mattress. Plush mattresses have a 19-21 pound indentation load deflection ranking and are suitable for those who sleep on their back, sides, or stomach. They give you additional support to relieve any back problems or joint pain. These contouring support mattresses adjust to your body for optimal comfort. However, they may be problematic if various people will be sleeping in the bed, causing the surface to sag if there is a significant difference in weight. Additionally, they are more likely to cave in over time, so your body won't be adequately supported when sleeping. These mattresses are built with a solid construction, making them more durable and able to sustain more weight. Less likely to cave in, they will provide proper support, even after prolonged use. However, they are thicker than most mattresses, so finding bedding that will cover the top and sides is much harder.

Our Top Ranking Mattresses:

	Product Name	Brand	Type	Size
Best Overall Score 1	Furniture of America MiBasics Payton Plush Euro Top 16-Inch Mattress	Furniture of America	euro top
Runner Up 2	Sealy Posturepedic Plush Pillow Top Queen-Size 16-Inch Mattress	Sealy Posturepedic	pillow top	queen
For Side Sleepers 3	Restonic Plush Memory Foam King-Size 16-Inch Mattress	Restonic	memory foam	king
4	Furniture of America MiBasics Plush Memory Foam King-Size 16-Inch Mattress	Furniture of America	memory foam	king

Our Top Ranking Mattresses

Best Overall Score

Furniture of America MiBasics Payton Plush Euro Top 16-Inch Mattress

Customer Rating

Brand

Furniture of America

Type

euro top

Size

Buy now on walmart

Runner Up

Sealy Posturepedic Plush Pillow Top Queen-Size 16-Inch Mattress

Customer Rating

Brand

Sealy Posturepedic

Type

pillow top

Size

queen

Buy now on Amazon

For Side Sleepers

Restonic Plush Memory Foam King-Size 16-Inch Mattress

Customer Rating

Brand

Restonic

Type

memory foam

Size

king

Buy now on Amazon

Furniture of America MiBasics Plush Memory Foam King-Size 16-Inch Mattress

Customer Rating

Brand

Furniture of America

Type

memory foam

Size

king

Buy now on walmart

Best Overall Score

Furniture of America MiBasics Payton Plush Euro Top 16-Inch Mattress

5.0 by user reviews

For a good night's rest and ultimate comfort, choose a Furniture of America MiBasics Payton Plush Euro Top Mattress. With a plush comfort level, this thick mattress is great for people who are looking for extra cushioning, without compromising durability and support. It features a 16-inch thickness, resulting in a bulky appearance that can be off-putting for some. Designed with a Euro top construction, it can't shift or lose its shape because the pillow layer is sewn underneath the cover. It has a no-flip design, so you don't have to do the chore of flipping your heavy mattress.

Pros

Plush mattress will keep your body comfortable and aligned all night long
Features a no-flip construction, eliminating the hassle that accompanies having to flip large mattress
Euro top construction adds an extra layer of padding

Cons

Plush comfort level can get lumpy or sag over time
16-inch thickness can tend to appear disproportional in some bed frames
Euro top construction is not the most durable

Buy now on walmart Read More

Runner Up

Sealy Posturepedic Plush Pillow Top Queen-Size 16-Inch Mattress

5.0 by user reviews

For a better night's sleep and endless comfort, choose a Sealy Posturepedic Plush Pillow Top Queen-Size Mattress. This thick mattress has a pillow top construction, which adds contouring and relieves hip pressure. It is designed to reduce tossing and turning, drastically improving your quality of sleep. It has pressure point relief technology, so any pain is diminished because of essential joint support.

Available in a queen-size, this thick mattress provides plenty of room to stretch out and sleep comfortably. It has a 16-inch thickness, resulting in a bulky appearance that can be off-putting for some. With a plush comfort level, it is ideal for those who like extra comfort. It has an edge support system, adding resistance around the edges of the mattress.

Pros

Plush mattress is suitable for all types of sleepers who are searching for the perfect mix of softness and support
Helps reduce tossing and turning at night, drastically improving your quality of sleep
Provides pressure point relief, minimizing pain or stiffness while you're sleeping

Cons

Queen-size doesn't provide ample space for couples
Plush comfort level can become lumpy or sag over time
16-inch thickness can tend to appear disproportional in some bed frames

Buy now on Amazon Read More

For Side Sleepers

Restonic Plush Memory Foam King-Size 16-Inch Mattress

5.0 by user reviews

If you want to ensure that your don't strain your back while you sleep, the Restonic Plush Memory Foam King-Size Mattress might be a great option. Available in a king-size, this thick mattress offers an ample amount of room to spread out and relax. It features a 16-inch thickness, resulting in a bulky appearance that can be off-putting for some. With a plush comfort level, it adds extra cushioning, without compromising support and durability. Featuring a memory foam construction, it accommodates every possible sleeping position. This thick mattress has a supportive design, which ensures proper spinal support and alignment.

Pros

Plush mattress for the perfect combination of softness and firmness
Supportive design ensures proper spinal support and alignment
King-size will provide maximum bed space

Cons

King-size does not fit in small rooms
Plush comfort level can get lumpy or sag over time
16-inch thickness can tend to appear disproportional in some bed frames

Buy now on Amazon Read More

Additional Picks

Furniture of America MiBasics Plush Memory Foam King-Size 16-Inch Mattress

5.0 by user reviews

For a better night's rest and endless comfort, choose a Furniture of America MiBasics Plush Memory Foam King-Size Mattress. This organic mattress has a 16-inch thickness, resulting in a bulky appearance. With a plush comfort level, it is ideal for those who love extra softness. This organic mattress is available in a king-size, so you can have as much space as possible.

Designed with a memory foam construction, this organic mattress reshapes itself to your body if you moved around in your sleep. It is constructed with organic materials, so it makes the air free of toxins. With five layers, this organic mattress helps with pressure point relief, better circulation, and motion isolation. It has memory foam and quilt foam layers.

Pros

Plush mattress for utmost comfort and softness
King-size is ideal for areas with a lot of space
Includes five layers, providing ultimate comfort and support

Cons

King-size does not fit in small rooms
Plush comfort level can become lumpy or sag over time
16-inch thickness can tend to appear disproportional in some bed frames

Buy now on walmart Read More

If You Need Help Making Your Choice, Here's Some More Information About the 16-Inch Plush Mattresses Available:

The Sizes Available for 16-Inch Plush Mattresses

King-Size Mattresses

Not sure whether to get a king-size mattress? Read on to learn a bit about them. These mattresses are ideal for master bedrooms and measure 76" X 80". They are suitable for couples, offering maximum space for two people. Something to consider is that they are heavy and large, making them difficult to move and flip. Additionally, they are not great for small areas, taking up a majority of the free space in the room. If you think that you might want to get a king-size mattress, here's one to take a look at.

Queen-Size Mattresses

In search of a roomy 16-inch plush mattress? These mattresses are perfect for master bedrooms and measure 60" X 80". They are built to adequately accommodate couples, providing enough space for two people. However, they are not ideal for areas with limited room, since they can make the area look somewhat cluttered. Another drawback is that they are smaller than king-size mattresses, so if you like having a wider sleeping area, you should consider getting a larger mattress. Want to get a queen-size mattress? Check out this one.

Mattress Type: Which One Is Right for You?

Memory Foam Mattresses

If you're thinking about getting a memory foam mattress, this 16-inch plush mattress could be a good choice for you. Built of various materials, memory foam mattresses provide just the right amount of comfort for you. They offer pressure point relief to properly align the spine. They come with superior motion isolation, so your partner's movements won't wake you up. However, memory foam mattresses aren't waterproof, so any interaction with moisture can cause degeneration and decrease their usable life. Additionally, they can smell a bit like chemicals initially, so you'll have to air them out for at least 24 hours before putting sheets on.

Pillow Top Mattresses

If you like to have the perfect balance between firmness and softness, you might want to consider getting a pillow top mattress. Here's one for you to look at. Moving heat away from your body, pillow top mattresses keep you from getting too warm throughout the night. They provide pressure-point relief by supporting the shoulders and hips. They offer an extra layer of padding to boast the appropriate comfort on your mattress. They feature a layer sewn to the top of the mattress, providing continual support all night long. With innovative, enhanced motion isolation technology, they will allow to wake up in the morning without disrupting your partner. However, they are expensive, so if you're shopping on a budget, this might not be the best option for you. In addition, they can smell a bit like chemicals initially, so you'll have to air them out for at least 24 hours before adding sheets.

Euro Top Mattresses

If you want a Euro top mattress, this 16-inch plush mattress might be a good choice. These Euro top mattresses are sewn a special way to give them a uniform look, transforming the overall appearance of your bedroom. Providing pressure-point relief, they adequately support your shoulders and hips in any sleeping position. They offer an extra layer of padding to boast the appropriate cushion on your mattress. Featuring firm edges, Euro top mattresses provide stable support and decrease roll-off.